10 DECEMBER 15-21, 2022 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | be a fourth phase, when wolves are so abun- dant that hunting them is allowed? According to Barnes, that’s a philosophical issue. “The states that are doing it are doing it because people in their states want it, and I don’t think people in Colorado want wolves to be a game species,” he said. “The language in Proposi- tion 114 defi ned wolves as a non-game species, and I think that was the voters’ intent.” Though hunting isn’t a wolf management strategy, the plan contemplates a variety of other tools, particularly education. “Both non-lethal and lethal tools are often temporary solutions to resolve confl ict,” Odell said at the meeting. “These tools are not implemented with the expectation that either of them will provide regular, long-term effectiveness. Non- lethal tools can be effective as a proactive preventative measure. These are techniques such as removing carcasses...utilizing range riders, aversive stimuli such as lights or noise, and other tools.” The plan would allow non-injurious haz- ing at all times, and proposes to allow poten- tially injurious but non-lethal hazing such as rubber bullets at all times, as well. It specifi es that lethal tools would only be used by fed- eral or state agency staff, or someone with a limited duration permit if agencies don’t have the resources. Lethal management is useful in the case of recurring depredations, he noted, and most effective shortly after depredation occurs. Only 4 percent of Montana’s wolves were removed through lethal control in 2020, according to Odell, and only one instance of lethal control occurred in Oregon in 2020. Even wolf advocates have recognized the need for occasional lethal control of wolves. A positive of Colorado’s plan is that it gives CPW discretion to determine when lethal control is appropriate while emphasizing that non-lethal methods are preferable, Barnes pointed out. No potentially injurious or lethal control methods can be employed unless the state obtains a 10(j) plan under the Endangered Species Act with U.S. Fish and Wildlife. Since wolves are federally listed as endangered, such measures would be illegal without a specifi c exemption. CPW has already re- quested that Fish and Wildlife designate wolves as an experimental population. During the December meeting, the part of the plan that received the most attention was chapter six, which deals with wolf-livestock interactions. The vote on Proposition 114 had shown a clear split between the Front Range and rural areas on the issue of wolf reintroduction. Luke Hoffman, game damage and com- mercial parks manager for CPW, said that the agency will provide fl adry — colored fl ags to deter wolves — and some scare devices to ranchers as needed. But confl ict minimiza- tion techniques won’t be required before ranchers are eligible for compensation in the case of death, injury and indirect losses such as low weaning weights or low concep- tion rates. Depredation confi rmations will be made by CPW on a preponderance-of- evidence basis, meaning that the event was more likely to be wolves than not. Compensation will be at fair market value and is capped at $8,000 per head of livestock. Veterinarian costs can also be covered; dogs will be compensated only if they were used for guarding or herding livestock. Because missing calves or young sheep are trickier to identify as having been killed by depredation, ranch- ers who have missing livestock under a year of age can be compensated for them if there is a confi rmed depredation in the same band, herd or parcel as the missing young animal. Ranchers can apply for a basic compen- sation ratio, which provides a more general compensation for missing or dead animals with less documentation, or itemized pro- duction losses, which provides for those situations and other indirect losses with more documentation required. Throughout the process of creating the draft, ranchers were insistent that indirect losses be part of the compensation plan. Wolf advocates were more hesitant to add such provisions. “The way the system is set up, somebody could get paid for all of their missing cattle just because they had one wolf depredation, which is, to me, it’s a little bit problematic,” Barnes said. “It’s going to create a situation where people feel like it’s a handout to the ranchers and, to some degree, they would have a point.” “There were some really good compro- mises,” says Renee Deal, who runs Sperry Livestock Corporation in Somerset with her family and was a member of the stake- holders group. “I don’t think anyone really got everything they wanted, but I think that that refl ects the fact that it’s a compromise.” The disagreement over compensation refl ects how people view wolves philosophi- cally as well as practically, making compro- mise diffi cult, according to Barnes. “If you think that normal means being able to ranch with no wolves or that normal is the absence of wolves and that any loss caused by wolves is a cost of wolves com- ing back, then you would maybe develop a program like this where the intent is to compensate livestock producers for every conceivable loss,” he says now. “But if your idea of normal is the full suite of native wildlife, including all of the predators, and if you view human activities like ranching as essentially an add-on to that, then you start to think, well, some production losses are a cost of doing business.” Chapter seven of the plan covers moni- toring, ungulate management, research and reporting. CPW has a goal of collaring two wolves per pack for research, but given the diffi culty of collaring, it will focus on collar- ing at least one member. It will also use hair and scat sampling and trail cameras to help indicate population abundance and monitor wolf health the way it monitors the health of other wildlife populations. CPW will research everything from social tolerance for wolves to wolf ecology and wolf interactions with other animals, issuing an- nual reports as required by statute. Research fi ndings will be included in those reports once they are peer-reviewed. But Brian Kurzel of the National Wildlife Federation, a stakeholders’ member, says he wants to see clarifi cation that CPW will use and share empirical data about social toler- ance and attitudes toward wolves in real time rather than waiting for peer review, in order to be more proactive. Rob Edward, strategic advisor for the Rocky Mountain Wolf Project, which was key to the passage of 114, says the state has gone above and beyond to accommodate di- verse perspectives as it works toward a plan. He’s been there from the start, he notes, and still trusts that his group’s vision of returning wolves to the state can come true. “While the draft plan certainly has some fl aws that we’ll want to see fi xed, we do think this is a good starting point,” he says. “Now it’s down to understanding the devil in the details and making sure the fi nal plan sets the stage for a free-roaming, self-sustaining population of wolves in Colorado for millen- nia to come. That’s success.” The fi nal chapter of the plan concerns funding. Many programs in the draft don’t currently exist, and will need to be funded through the Colorado Legislature, at least temporarily. The goal is to fi nd a long-term funding source outside of the political process. Commissioners asked for specifi cs on how much funding would be required. Ac- cording to Reid DeWalt, CPW assistant director of aquatic, terrestrial and natural resources, the agency needs some adaptive fl exibility on funding but can share estimates at the next commission meeting. The nearly 300-page plan released De- cember 9 is still a draft, and the public will have the chance to comment in public hear- ings over the next several months; CPW has targeted the February 23 commission meeting as the fi nal date to provide guidance to staffers for the fi nal plan. A schedule of commission meetings is on the CPW website, and written comment can be submitted to wolfengagementco.org. Deal encourages Coloradans to get involved. “It’s been a challenging process, and it’s kind of put me way outside my comfort zone,” she acknowledges. “It made me feel like I actu- ally was able to do something to help, because a lot of people on the Western Slope are really, really angry about the whole thing, and I was, too. It kind of helped me work through that anger and get to a place where I felt like we could actually come up with some solutions.” Email the author at [email protected]. News continued from page 8 A wolf release by the National Park Service in 1995. Wolf packs can now be found in Yellowstone National Park. DAN STAHLER NATIONAL PARK SERVICE