8 DECEMBER 5-11, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | hiring process for all booksellers led entirely by me and all four store managers. Based on the results of those interviews, we let go of a handful of booksellers at Colfax. There were also certain offi ce roles at the Tattered Cover that overlapped with operations that are now covered by Barnes & Noble, so the employees who previously held those posi- tions were let go.” Alosa, who had worked at the Colfax store for three years, was shown the door on the same day as Mack. “Someone was fi red out of the blue the day before,” Alosa recalls. “Everybody was freaking out that day when they heard the news, and management promised us there would be no more fi rings that day. They were honest about that. They waited until the next day to fi re Alex and me.” In addition to being given no notice, Alosa was offered no severance — unless a certain stipulation was met. “They said I could have two weeks’ worth of severance pay, but I didn’t take it,” he says. “I would have had to sign a non-disparagement agreement to get the money. Two weeks of minimum-wage pay to stay silent.” Dempsey doesn’t believe that Barnes & Noble acted in bad faith. “They had the right,” he says. “There’s no legal obligation for them to keep any employees on other than just, you know, how people might feel about the company. But there’s no legal obligation. The agree- ment said ‘substantially all,’ and so there was there was room in there.” Dempsey refers to the firings as “consolidating the number of booksell- ers.” At the same time, he says, “Booksellers have a lot more control now. That’s the methodology. It’s now a bookseller-led store. The initiative here is to give more power to the book- sellers.” James Daunt, CEO of Barnes & Noble, echoes that sentiment. “Let booksell- ers be booksellers,” he says. “Leave them alone and let them do what they do.” Daunt began his career as a bookseller himself in his native England, where he founded a string of stores called Daunt Books. B&N appointed him its CEO in 2019, following the chain’s purchase for $683 million by the United Kingdom-based hedge fund Elliott Advisors. By then, he already had a soft spot for Tattered. “I remember going to the Tattered Cover for the fi rst time in the ’90s,” he says of the massive Cherry Creek store. “I had already heard so much about it. It was this legendary place.” So when Tattered entered bankruptcy proceedings, Daunt jumped at the chance to be part of its legacy. “We want to preserve the culture of the Tattered Cover,” he says. “We just wanted to put books on the shelves. That’s it.” A Real Page-Turner The Tattered Cover’s tribulations since 2020 have devolved into a lot of fi nger- pointing. Spearman, however, doesn’t feel he is above blame. “One thing I’ve refl ected upon since leaving the Tattered Cover is I should have done more,” he says. “I should have deepened myself within that family and done more to try to preserve that familial vibe. But, you know, the Tattered Cover is one of those organizations where people are not working because of the compensation. They’re not working there because they are fascinated about retail. They’re working there because they love books and love their community. Put this together, and you have that family feel. “It’s increasingly hard to have a business like that right now,” he continues, “just with all of the macro factors that are going on, whether it’s infl ation or the cost of hous- ing. But I think, in many ways, that actually created an even stronger bond amongst the staff when I was there. They knew that they were trying to do something that was incredibly improbable, and I think there was a pride that they could accomplish that. But change is diffi cult. Businesses have to make decisions that allow those businesses to suc- ceed, and not everyone’s going to be happy with that. The Tattered Cover is something that we as Coloradans are proud to say we created, that we support and that we have. The Tattered Cover has to succeed.” On that point, Spearman and Dempsey agree. “Like most Coloradans, I feel it would be unacceptable to think of a world with- out the Tattered Cover,” Dempsey says. “People don’t understand how close we were to closing the store at multiple points in 2023 and 2024. We fought the battle. Now they’ve signed a new twenty-year lease at the Colfax store. This is a generational commitment to that location.” Spearman wishes that Tattered’s survival hadn’t come at such a cost. “The Tat- tered Cover, to me, is known for two things,” he says. “One, obviously, books, but second, being a Colorado treasure. And so now, for the owners to not be remotely based in Colorado is frustrating. “I hope they can suc- ceed,” he adds, “but the challenge is that the Tat- tered Cover is more than just a retail environment. It’s a place where people feel ownership. That’s what it means to me. And I think that the employees are part of that DNA. If you’re Barnes & Noble and you’re going to make a bid to pur- chase the Tattered Cover, you have to be signed up for those employees and the type of development that’s needed for that team. If you didn’t want to do that, if you wanted to re-interview ev- eryone immediately, you shouldn’t have bought the organization, because you’re fundamentally changing what it is. To me, that’s not right.” Mack and Alosa were both hired dur- ing Spearman’s reign, which saw its share of fi rings and instability, not to mention abysmal spirits. “The fi nancial problems were so severe back then,” Alosa recalls. “There would be, like, four books on every shelf. The lights were busted. The carpet was dirty. Your entire job was telling people why you don’t have Huck Finn in stock, then having them say, ‘Well, what kind of bookstore are you?’ And that was every single day, over and over.” Mack also acknowledges Tattered’s rocky history — and current reality. “Obviously, things were not in the best shape before Barnes & Noble took over. Spirits were col- lectively down there even before the Barnes & Noble thing. People would come and be, like, ‘Oh, I’m just going to get this book on Amazon because you guys can’t do it.’ It was really limiting, but we were sticking together. When I say the staff was like a family, it really was. We had each other’s backs. We were trying to fi gure out how to do this, how to survive in the bankruptcy. Like, I came up with this idea, a blind date with a book, in order to sell dead stock that we had on the shelves that was unreturnable. We would all just come up with little ideas like that. We were really trying as hard as we could to keep that business open because it was personal to us, because we loved it.” Tattered’s acquisition by B&N still feels like a mismatch to Mack. “When Barnes & Noble took over,” Mack says, “they were saying, ‘Hey, this is the Tattered Cover. The name Barnes & Noble will be nowhere in the store.’ And then we got all this stuff, like machines, that said Barnes & Noble on them. It defi nitely feels like they took the Tattered Cover and gutted everything out, and now we’re just living in its skin. It’s like this parasite has taken over, and it’s trying to convince everybody that it’s still the same.” Despite their treatment by the new own- ers, Mack and Alosa both say they want Tat- tered to persevere, even if they have qualms about how that perseverance might look. “I don’t think Barnes & Noble is an intrin- sic evil in the same way Amazon is,” Alosa says. “It’s good that there are still physical stores that sell books in the world. But with anything like Barnes & Noble, you’re going to see it get worse and worse. Just a few years back we had stores that were more personal- ized and local, but I think that’s just going to get leaner and leaner. It is kind of a bargain with the devil, I guess. But I don’t want to see the Tattered Cover entirely gone, either.” Email the author at [email protected]. Battered Cover continued from page 6 Merak Alosa refused to sign Tattered’s non-disparagement agreement after being fi red. Tattered Cover’s future as a booklover’s paradise remains unwritten. EVAN SEMÓN EVAN SEMÓN