5 NOVEMBER 16-22, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | CONTENTS | LETTERS | NEWS | NIGHT+DAY | CULTURE | CAFE | MUSIC | Following his trial in Denver,Timothy McVeigh — convicted of killing 168 people in the 1995 bombing of the Murrah Building in Okla- homa City — was sent to a federal prison in Terre Haute, Indiana. Every few weeks, Ellis Armistead visited him on death row. A private investigator in the Mile High City, Ar- mistead was assisting the attorneys working on McVeigh’s appeals process, which lasted several years. By late spring 2001, McVeigh had decided to drop his appeals against his lawyer’s advice, not wanting to die in prison decades later. “I understand why he did this,” Ar- mistead says in his slow Southern drawl. “I’ve had two clients commit suicide in jail.” The investigator found McVeigh calm and considerate, treating corrections offi cers well and regularly asking about Armistead’s staff. Once the inmate began correspond- ing with author Gore Vidal and following his March 2000 60 Minutes interview — Armistead was present for that — he also noticed McVeigh’s growing narcissism. He saw no remorse in the young man. “I observed the monster in him,” he says, “and the human being. Sometimes there’s a fi ne line between the two.” Before his death, McVeigh confi ded that he had a “higher being” — a remark that left Armistead wondering if he could say the same thing about himself. One of his tasks was traveling to upstate New York to inform the condemned man’s father, William, that McVeigh would soon be executed. “It was a snowy night in Buffalo when I drove out to Bill’s house,” Armistead recalls. “He was a great guy. When I told him what was about to happen, he said, ‘I love my son, but I believe in the death penalty. Do you want a highball?’” The investigator was with McVeigh in Indi- ana twenty minutes before he received the le- thal cocktail. He’d asked the P.I. to be a witness at his execution, but Armistead had declined. “I could deal with him better once he was gone,” he remembers. “I pulled him off the gurney.” An autopsy wasn’t performed because people were clamoring to buy McVeigh’s body parts, even strands of his hair, and the authorities didn’t want to risk that. After many funeral homes had turned him down, Armistead found a mortuary that would carry out the cremation. One of his assistants put the ashes in her backpack and took them to the airport; on the plane she sat next to a journalist who’d covered the execution. He began telling her about the widespread rumors that the ashes had immediately been fl own out of the country. “He didn’t know that they were right under her seat,” Armistead says. “Sometimes in this job, you have to laugh to keep from crying.” Back in Denver, he took the ashes home, where his employees were unwinding after the long McVeigh ordeal with pizza and beer. When his wife, a trauma nurse in an intensive-care unit, found out what was in the backpack, she was livid. “Get that out of here,” she told him, and he did. This wasn’t the fi rst time he’d provoked his wife with his involvement in a high-profi le case. He’d once mistakenly put a victim’s hands in the freezer at home. continued on page 6