8 NOVEMBER 16-22, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | A call came in about a traffi c accident, and he was the fi rst offi cer on the scene, where a boy had been run over by a truck. Dismounting from his motorcycle, he walked up to the body laid out in the middle of the road, covered by a sheet. In the distance, he could hear people moaning. Removing the sheet, he saw only a torso. Onlookers had gathered and were all pointing or nodding in the same direction, about fi fty yards away. Following their lead, he found the boy’s head and realized that the moaning was coming from the victim’s mother and father. He asked for backup. After fi nishing work that day, he drove to his parents’ home to tell them what had happened. They didn’t want to hear about it, so he went to a steakhouse, pok- ing at his food and thinking about what he’d just seen, telling himself that it was just part of the job and he shouldn’t let it bother him. He could deal with it, tuck it away somewhere and move on. “I was pretty good at pushing things aside,” he recalls, “because I had a strong stomach and didn’t get fl ustered.” He never spoke with anyone in any depth — inside or outside of law enforcement — about this experience. “If anyone asked me about it,” he says, “I gave them the short, sanitized version. I took pride in my ability to handle anything that came down the pike and then go home and sleep well that night.” After a few years with the De- catur department, he transferred his police skills to Lakewood, Colo- rado. The fi rst day he reported for work, the desk offi cer, knowing that Armistead came from Alabama, greeted him with, “Where’s your white sheet?” — implying that he was in the Ku Klux Klan. Starting off in patrol, he again saw a lot of suicides (a man shot himself in front of Armistead) while using police resources to earn a master’s degree in public administration/criminal justice. He was quickly promoted to homicide, and his fi rst case involved Ron Lyle, the boxer who’d lost a world heavyweight championship fi ght against Muhammad Ali. Lyle was accused of gunning down a man in his home, but was ac- quitted after his attorney claimed self-defense. Armistead was shot at twice — on the street near Sheridan Boulevard, and at Wadsworth and Hampden, when he was wearing civilian clothes on his way to the dry cleaners. Driving past a bank, he noticed unusual activity and stopped. As he entered the business, a robbery was unfolding, so he pretended to be a customer and joined the others in the teller line. The robber took the bank manager outside at gunpoint and Armistead pursued, drawing his weapon and blowing out the man’s car windows in an exchange of fi re. Backup arrived, the offender was arrested, and Armistead was asked to retrace his steps during the gunfi ght. He couldn’t, because stress had erased his memory of the events. Other offi cers told him that similar things had happened to them. He went back to work and appeared to be unaffected. “It takes a lot,” he likes to say, “to get me excited.” But as he neared forty, his nightmares intensifi ed; he was losing sleep, slipping into depression and taking Prozac, the fi rst of many meds he’d consume to alleviate his condition. Not much changed, even after he left his job in Lakewood. Hired as a criminal investigator in Colo- rado’s 14th Judicial District, he covered a large section of the state’s northwest. He relocated to Steamboat Springs, but the fl ashbacks, anxiety and nightmares con- tinued, scaring both him and his wife. He was losing rest and signifi cant weight. One of his cases involved a mother, father and their eighteen-month-old son, who’d all been shot in the back of the head and left in a ditch. In the morgue, Armistead held the child in his arms and promised himself that now, fi nally, he’d get away from the criminal justice system. But he didn’t leave his job. Badly in need of a respite, the Armisteads and another couple took a two-month trip to Nepal and Thailand. They had no itinerary, just got off the plane and began trekking across the two countries, hiking and absorb- ing the beauty of the landscapes and jungles, sleeping on dirt fl oors and interacting with the local population. For the fi rst time in years, Armistead let down. The people in Nepal had so little, but seemed happier than those in America who had so much. Filling each day with exploration and physical ex- ertion, he enjoyed what he later called “the most peaceful time in my life.” Back in Steamboat Springs, he had to listen to the full confession, including many grisly details, as the triple-homicide killer laid out his crime. Armistead’s depression and panic attacks resumed. He quit his job and became a process server in Steamboat until word of his career switch reached Denver, where prominent defense attorneys sought him out to be their private investiga- tor on criminal cases. He resettled in the Mile High City and crossed over, as some in law enforcement put it, to “the dark side” — now representing those accused of serious offenses. One detective nastily asked him how he could live with himself. “I thought we were friends,” Armistead says. As a P.I., he clearly defi ned his role: He was an investigator, not an advocate for the clients. His job was to uncover bad evidence and bad alibis and pass them along to the lawyers so they wouldn’t get ambushed in court by something they didn’t know. Sev- enty percent of what he dug up fell into this category. He was good at digging, at being discreet, at getting people to talk to him, and at staying calm and neutral in all kinds of diffi cult situations. He’d never again carry a gun, but he couldn’t escape violent crime. His fi rst P.I. case came when a young man shot and killed a state trooper near Idaho Springs, particu- larly diffi cult since Armistead had spent the past seventeen years in law enforcement. His career presented a quandary. He liked using his intelligence to investigate, liked the action around the criminal justice system and learning things not everyone knew: which police offi cer was jumping out of which re- porter’s bedroom window at midnight; how attorneys hid microphones in their briefcases to make secret recordings of their adversaries; and what cops did to unwind on road trips — starting with a whole lot of beer. But the depression and nightmares continued, along with his consumption of meds. “I think I’ve taken everything available for anxiety,” he says. He didn’t want to stop being an investiga- tor, but didn’t know how to combat the toll it was taking. “There’s an adrenaline rush that comes when you get involved in murder cases, es- pecially if they’re high-profi le,” says Greta Lindecrantz, a Denver P.I. who’s worked with Armistead on several occasions and been involved in nineteen death penalty cases. “But there’s also a need for sensitivity. That helps you do the job, but it also makes you vulnerable. You’re dealing with the loss of a human being and the loss of a member of a community. You have to be sensitive to that, while also trying to gain the trust of your clients. They may be mentally ill, and you try to discover what led them to this moment. “Ellis is very good at doing all of these things and at being intuitive, but this opens him up to that sensitivity and vulnerability,” she continues. “You absorb everything from these experiences. Everything you see, hear and smell, your body remembers and stores. I can recall when the smell of blood was so strong at a crime scene that I had to get away and couldn’t tell anyone what I was experiencing. A lot of dark humor surrounds this work as a coping mechanism, but it’s not healthy. People pay a price for this with heart attacks or cancer or drinking too much.” One night after going to a bar with Ar- mistead, Lindecrantz followed him home in her car, worried he wouldn’t make it there safely. Another night he called a well-known Denver TV reporter to come pick him up at a tavern and then slept at his residence. When not working or heading out for a drink, he jogged alone during the week to decompress, and on weekends ran eight to ten miles with others. It was good for his physical health, but it didn’t stop the nightmares or panic attacks. In 1980, PTSD had been offi cially pro- posed as an anxiety disorder. A decade later, Armistead was diag- Paying the Price continued from page 6 continued on page 10 GETT Y IMAGES/MICHAEL SMITH Ellis Armistead as a Lakewood cop, before he became a P.I. whose jobs included working with the Ramsey family at their Boulder home. COURTESY OF ELLIS ARMISTEAD