6 NOVEMBER 16-22, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | By 2001, his marriage was starting to teeter. Armistead was 51 and had been in the criminal justice system for 28 years, working for both law enforcement and defense teams. A decade earlier, he’d begun having severe nightmares and violent fl ashbacks. He couldn’t watch movies, TV shows or documentaries featuring bloodshed. Some nights he thrashed so hard he had to sleep on the couch. In the fi rst years of his career, police departments had offered little or no help for those suffering from emo- tional trauma, in part because acknowledging such things might open them up to liability issues (and many offi cers didn’t want to admit to having these problems). Knowing something was wrong and that he needed professional help, Armistead sought out a therapist. When he fi nished describing his employment situation, she replied, “You need to fi nd someone else. I can’t handle this.” She couldn’t handle him being called to the worst crime scenes and dealing with the people most affected by a tragedy — those who couldn’t comprehend or accept what had just happened to a loved one, or those who couldn’t believe what a loved one had done to others. In virtually every situation, Armistead was a steady presence when oth- ers struggled to cope. But off duty, especially at night, the nightmares and fl ashbacks kept coming. Sometimes, he drank too much or had memory lapses or dark thoughts about his future. He was hardly alone. In 2020, 116 police offi cers committed suicide. In 2021, the number rose to 150. Badge of Life, an organization specializing in preventing law enforcement suicides, conservatively estimates that 150,000 of- fi cers suffer from PTSD. “We found that around 65 percent of po- lice offi cers will have PTSD,” says its website. “Out of these individuals, only 39 percent will receive treatment for their disorder. One police academy director estimates that about 15 percent of any police department’s offi cers are in a burnout phase at any one time, and that 5 to 7 percent are ‘crispy critters’ who are totally burned out.” The thirty years that Armistead has been a private investigator parallel the explosion of interest in true crime, with a glut of books, documentaries, fi lms, podcasts, radio and TV programs, and limited series. The subject has consumed a wide chunk of the Internet with chat rooms, forums, investigative teams and countless amateur sleuths, producing good results and bad: a number of solved cold cases and some fanatical behavior around certain high-profi le murders. Every day, one sees heartbreaking posts on Facebook about someone searching for a missing relative or seeking justice for a long-ago homicide. Real people, of course, live behind these tragedies, suffering mostly in silence after events they’ll never recover from. Armistead has been with them when the heat from the police and the media was most intense, and the impact of this has left its mark on him. They say that once a man has been in prison, he never loses the tension in his shoulders, always aware that someone may be sneaking up behind him to cause harm. With Armistead, the stress is locked into his features. His blue eyes are wide open, as if he’s just seen something he shouldn’t have. His pupils constantly move side to side, wary, the prelude to a wince. When he becomes self-conscious, his reddish face turns crimson. If you ask him to spill a few secrets about his work or to talk about his accomplishments, the relentlessly modest investigator shrugs and says, “Well, it’s really not like that.” In the middle of a painful story, his voice catches and you wonder if he might break down. His presence is haunting — not just when you’re with him, but for hours afterward. He carries with him the weight of his experience. Over decades of writing true crime books, I’ve met countless attorneys, police offi cers, criminals, victims and their families, private investigators, media members and courtroom personnel. All of them, including reporters who’ve covered numerous murder trials or the atrocities of war or terrorism, deal with residual trauma. Some fi nally decide they can’t witness the results of any more violence and move on to other assignments. Everyone within the legal system is assigned a role that they dutifully play. Almost no one tells you what they really think or feel about a particular case. Most P.I.s have poker faces, revealing nothing while squeezing you for any scrap of information they might fi nd useful. Even if they want to talk, they’ve often signed non-disclosure agreements preventing them from opening up about their work or violating the attorney-client privilege that lawyers have with defendants. Because of these barriers and others, the people you meet when writing true crime inevitably end up as characters in a story, no matter how hard you try to penetrate their facade. You always want to know more about them than you do, more than you can. In the spring of 2023, Armistead, whom I’d met in the late 1990s when he was em- ployed by the attorneys for John and Patsy Ramsey following the death of their daugh- ter, JonBenét, reached out to me. This had never happened before with a private in- vestigator: You have to seek them out, and then they probably still won’t talk. During our phone conversation, Armistead didn’t say much, and his purpose in calling seemed vague. He might be willing to speak about his experiences, but he wasn’t quite sure, and there were things he couldn’t get into, and… Our discussion didn’t go anywhere, but I never stopped thinking about him. Five months passed, and I decided to dial his number to see if he wanted to get together. He was noncommittal, saying he’d think about it. Three days later, I sent an email asking if he’d like to get a cup of coffee. Fifty years into his career, he was ready to talk. Ellis Armistead was born on the Fourth of July 1950 in Nashville, Tennessee. His father was a NASA engineer and his mother the director of nursing at a local hospital. His family moved to California for two years for his dad’s job before settling in Decatur, a city of roughly 50,000 in northern Alabama. Around age twelve, Ellis entered an awkward stage. He had a growth spurt, shooting up three inches in a year (he’s six feet seven), and was uncoordinated. Students made fun of him, and his basketball coach said that he was “too lazy to raise a fi shing pole.” After a few scrapes at school, he shoved a teacher, and his father sent him to Marion Military Institute for a year, where he learned to study and control his temper. One day his dad drove him to a Decatur sporting goods store/pawn shop and asked the owner to take on his son, with no pay, so he could get some work experience (the owner felt so guilty that he paid him under the table). Ellis’s upper-middle-class back- ground had insulated him from those who came into the shop: the poor, the needy, drunks and dopers, drifters, grifters, and gun-loving citizens. He liked dealing with them, liked their rawness and their stories. He sold a lot of the $14.95, .22-caliber pistols known as “Saturday Night Specials” and a lot of gunpowder that customers fed to their canines to make them more aggressive dur- ing dogfi ghts. A co-worker with a side hustle in cock fi ghting wanted to go into business with Ellis, giving him some magazines to take home and study. The venture lasted until his mother found them in his bedroom. His father had his future all planned out: college at Vanderbilt, where his parents had gone, and then into banking or law. He did well at Vanderbilt and well enough on the LSAT to get into law school, but there was a problem: Ellis found both banking and lawyering boring. After graduation, he tried sell- ing insurance — for a week — before gravitating back to the pawn shop. Cops frequented the store and told him to apply for a job with the Decatur Police Department: It was exciting to be an authority fi gure, to ride a motorcycle, to carry a fi rearm, and to learn the local ways of law enforcement. He was soon hired, and his fellow offi cers initiated him in the station’s DUI room by making him drink a cup of moonshine whiskey. The next morning when he reported for duty, the chief handed him a badge and said, “Now you’re an offi cial sono- fabitch!” His annual salary was $6,000, and his parents were mortifi ed by his choice of employment. His superiors quickly discovered that he was a “terrible shot” on the fi ring range, and they almost suspended him (he had his partner take target practice for him and turned in the results as if they were his own). The job was many things, but not boring. He dealt with bootleggers, dogs attacking him when he knocked on doors, and citizens enraged with the police. His towering height caused some shorter men to challenge him to fi ght, but he always tried to duck the “ankle biters.” When he came upon husbands and wives who were drunk and quarreling, he “divorced” them to calm them down, a trick he’d picked up watching The Andy Griffi th Show. Racial issues were ever-present. If there was a late-night shooting and the victim was Black, the police often wouldn’t go to the scene until the next day. When a dispatcher alerted patrol offi cers that a car full of African Americans was approaching, he’d say that “a load of coal is coming your way.” Working a local football game, Armistead got ensnared in a race riot and was pelted with rocks and other hand-launched missiles. All that was minor compared to the mur- ders and suicides he witnessed. At 23, he was getting inured to the smell of death. “I was not prepared for the violence I was exposed to,” he says. Paying the Price continued from page 5 continued on page 8 Ellis Armistead today (above), more than twenty years after he saw Tim McVeigh twenty minutes before his execution. JOYCE SINGUL AR WIKIPEDIA CC