10 NOVEMBER 16-22, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | nosed with the condition and began seeing a psychiatrist, a relationship that would last for the next 22 years, until she retired. Then, after a false start or two, he found another one. He was trying hard to cope with his job and to be proactive with his mental health. “When you observed Ellis, you could see and feel his humanity, and that made it easier to show your own vulnerability and humanity,” says Lindecrantz. “He treated me with great respect, was very collaborative, and listened to what I had to say. That isn’t true of every male private investigator I’ve worked with. Some of them didn’t want to hear my opinions. Away from work, Ellis could do all the ‘old boy’ things, but on the job he treated women very well. At one point he had about a dozen employees, and all of them were women.” As the 1990s unfolded, a new reality added to the pressure and stress, bringing the media and public into the criminal justice system as never before. The Internet was now in play, and the true crime phenomenon was explod- ing. Everyone was under more scrutiny as Colorado became the epicenter of three crimes that made national headlines. Armistead’s initial death penalty case didn’t quite reach that level. In 1993, nine- teen-year-old Nathan Dunlap killed four people at a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant in Aurora. When Armistead met the young man in the county jail for his fi rst legal advise- ment, Dunlap had covered himself with his own feces; the investigator had to cover his nose to endure the smell. Dunlap was “out of control,” and the P.I. felt an instant dislike, if not revulsion, for him. His work on the case didn’t impact just him, but also his wife. “Why,” she pointedly asked him one day, “am I ironing Nathan Dunlap’s clothes?” Over time, Armistead’s view of the pris- oner began to change. With the help of the corrections system, Dunlap attempted to rehabilitate himself and now mentors other inmates. He calls Armistead every year on his birthday and Thanksgiving. “When the case started,” Armistead says, “I didn’t understand as much about mental illness as I do today. You can’t put rational thinking onto irrational acts. Nathan has become an example of someone who can make his own life in prison and be produc- tive. Most people aren’t beyond redemption, if given the right support.” In 2020, after Colorado voted to abolish the death penalty, Governor Jared Polis commuted Dunlap’s death sentence to life in prison without parole. Armistead’s reputation as an investigator was growing, and he drew in famous clients, including Aspen’s Hunter Thompson. After getting into a bar fi ght, Dr. Gonzo contacted him seeking legal help. He began ringing him up in the middle of the night, complaining about his situation and causing the P.I. to back away. Armistead’s feelings about the late author are terse: “He was an idiot.” In late 1996, Armistead and those in his running group caught a news bulletin — something about the six-year-old daughter of a wealthy businessman found dead in the basement of their Boulder home. “That one won’t take long to solve,” Armistead casually remarked to the others. After John and Patsy Ramsey returned to Colorado following their infamous January 1, 1997, CNN interview about the murder of JonBenét, Armistead’s phone rang. The prestigious Denver law fi rm of Haddon, Morgan and Foreman tapped him to be the Ramseys’ private investigator. He was soon driving the family around town as they scurried from one place to another to avoid the media, especially the tabloid reporters who’d descended on Boulder and were con- ducting round-the-clock surveillance on the parents, swinging from trees onto the roof of their house at night to look for clues. When Armistead suggested to his wife that they let the Ramseys stay with them for a while, the idea met with strong resistance. With the Ramseys trapped in the frenzy, the P.I. made a point of getting JonBenét’s brother, nine-year-old Burke, away from the action, taking him outside to play in the street with his electric cars. Before long, a “tabloid clown” came after the investigator himself, breaking into his bank account and offering his younger brother, Steve, $50,000 to deliver dirt on his sibling. Nothing came of this, except Armistead’s anger. “If it had been me,” he says, “I’d have taken the money and just made something up for them.” When the Ramseys publicly declared they had the best investigative minds in the business working to solve the murder, Armistead and his staff were bemused. The case was turning out to be far more baffl ing than the P.I. — and countless others — had fi rst imagined. At the height of the Ramsey hysteria, when “the crazies” began showing up at Armistead’s offi ce unannounced with theories about the killer, he installed a stick- up alarm system (designed to stop burglars) that sent an alert to the police. He’d testify before the Ramsey grand jury, but after three years he quit the case because he didn’t like the leaks to the media or the dynamics between the district attorney, the press and the defense team. He was particularly an- noyed that the aging Bill McReynolds, who’d played Santa Claus for the Ramseys at their Christmas parties, had died with accusations of murdering the child hanging over him. “That stigma,” Armistead says, “never leaves you.” More than a quarter-century after the crime, no one has been arrested for it, and Armistead retains cabinets full of leads on the homicide. Every year, a handful of women call him to say that their ex-husbands are good for the murder and should be taken into custody. He remains tight-lipped about the girl’s death, but allows that the “intruder theory” — of someone coming into the Ramsey house that night and carrying out the murder in a wine cellar in the basement — doesn’t hold up. “The first time I was in the Ramseys’ home,” he says, “it took me ten minutes of walking around just to fi nd the wine cellar. You’d have to be very familiar with the layout of the house to know where that is.” Like Armistead, Greta Lindercrantz has also worked numerous high-profi le cases — and paid for it. “Death threats, intimidation, being chased — it all comes with the job now,” she says. “I was pinned up against a wall by a reporter, and I started hitting and kicking back. I hit his camera, and he said, ‘Don’t ever touch my camera.’ I’ve had people waiting for me in my driveway when I got home. It was terrifying. I also have PTSD. “What Ellis and I have gone through,” she continues, “is common in our profes- sion. People go along and do their jobs, and then they snap and can’t do it anymore. It’s a failure to recognize what’s happening to you on a daily basis. You’re doing your work and getting things done, but you don’t see what’s happening to you personally.” On April 20, 1999, Armistead was in Cali- fornia speaking with a suspect in a triple homicide. Leaving the jail, he checked his pager, now completely full of messages. He called his offi ce and was told to return to Denver immediately. His staff had been contacted by a lawyer and ordered to go pick up the parents of Eric Harris, one of the shooters in the massacre inside Columbine High School that day. It wasn’t yet clear if Harris and the other shooter, Dylan Klebold, were dead or alive. Armistead’s employees phoned law enforcement and learned they were deceased. His staff members drove Katherine and Wayne Harris to the Warwick Hotel in downtown Denver, checked them in under Armistead’s name, and waited for him to arrive. When he walked into the room, Katherine Harris was curled into a fetal posi- tion and sobbing. Wayne Harris came up to the investigator and said, “Just fl ush him!” Armistead’s job was to keep the couple secure for the next few weeks, as they moved into and out of a series of hotels. During that time, he watched as “some of the nic- est people I’ve ever met” tried to accept the horror of what their son had done. “The father and mother,” he says, “were collateral damage in Eric’s crime. I don’t think people understand what that really means and how many others are affected by major crimes: families, victims, fi rst re- sponders, judges, juries, law enforcement, witnesses, lawyers and private investiga- tors. After things began to settle down, the parents went back and lived in their home. The neighbors made a point of running off the press so they’d be left alone. I thought that was commendable.” Some years after Columbine, a Phoenix attorney called Armistead following a mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso, Texas, leav- ing 23 dead and 22 wounded. The lawyer wanted him to join the defense team, but he’d learned to say no. “I’d just fi nished a prison gang case,” he says, “and I told the man, ‘I don’t want this case, and you shouldn’t, either. If you take it, your wife will kill you if I don’t do that fi rst.’” In 2001, when he was transporting Timothy McVeigh’s ashes, Armistead’s psychiatrist called just to ask how he was doing. “It was very comforting to hear her voice,” he says. “At the time I thought I felt fi ne, but maybe I was dulled out and didn’t feel anything.” In 2004, his marriage ended. In 2005, in a downward spiral, he reached out to his sister, Ellen, in Seattle. He’d been diagnosed with Treatment Resistant Depression and the panic attacks had returned. With help from his family, he entered a Nashville fa- cility and was put in group therapy, where he was expected to “spill my guts about my problems.” He couldn’t do this, because non- disclosure agreements prevented him from speaking openly about his criminal cases. He left the group and for thirty days went one-on-one with a resident psychiatrist, opening up about his condition. “I didn’t feel I was good enough,” he says of that period, “even though people were tell- ing me I was good. Some days I didn’t think I was human because I wasn’t feeling things. The thirty days didn’t help me.” He went back to work, but the anxiety continued. In 2013, he was having night sweats, traveling constantly, and drove out of an airport terminal and rear-ended a car. He’d soon be diagnosed with stage 4 non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, which can be fatal, and spent six months in a Nashville hospital. Away from Denver and his offi ce, he was fi nally able, as he’d done more than two decades earlier in the Far East, to let down and fi nd some peace. Finishing up the rigors and aftereffects of chemotherapy, he went back to work. In 2016, he was awarded the Lifetime Achievement Award from the Professional Private Investiga- tors Association of Colorado. A year later, he started electro-shock treatments to end the nightmares and other symptoms, but “it didn’t make much difference,” he says. In 2018, he tried ketamine, but it, too, had little impact. In- vestigating a murder case near Pagosa Springs, he became disoriented, his GPS app failed, and he got lost on a Native American reservation. “They attributed this to the ketamine,” he says. Driving around the reservation, his car Paying the Price continued from page 8 Ellis Armistead also worked for the parents of one of the Columbine killers. JEFFERSON COUNT Y