10 OCTOBER 5-11, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | things like staffi ng and low wages when their departments have the same issues. “Blaming it on staffi ng is pretty hard for me to accept, honestly,” he says. “We have staffi ng issues at the district attorney’s offi ce and are still getting these cases prosecuted. We’re still getting our job done.” Kelly echoes Mason’s sentiments. “We have been told repeatedly that the state hospital is experiencing a staffi ng shortage,” she says. “As far as I am aware, that is the only cited cause of CMHHIP’s utter failure as a state organization. This explanation is unac- ceptable, and represents, in my opinion, a complete failure of leadership at CMHHIP.” Tied by a tight budget that makes it tough to fi nd lawyers in the rural 4th District, Kelly says she’s still managed to make things work — recruiting and hiring lawyers to put in her courtrooms because “that is the challenge as a leader to solve.” So why can’t the state hospital do the same thing? “It is inconceivable to me that CMHHIP continues to use the excuse of inability to recruit professionals when they are spending tens of millions of dollars to pay non-com- pliance fi nes,” Kelly says. “The institution does not have a recruiting problem, it has a leadership problem. Recruiting challenges are solvable, and they clearly have taxpayer money to solve them. Instead, they continue to use the staff shortage excuse to utterly fail to do the only job they have been mandated by the state to do.” The Colorado Department of Human Services, which oversees the state hospital, offers multiple reasons for what, specifi cally, has caused the problems: “The delays in the competency system are due to two main factors: Dramatic increase in referrals for competency services...[and] nursing and physician staff shortages,” says Jordan Saenz, communications manager for the CDHS-run Offi ce of Civil and Forensic Mental Health, which is in charge of the state hospital system. “Fiscal Year 2022-23 had an 80.4 percent increase in inpatient restoration treatment court orders since Fiscal Year 2017-18,” Saenz reports. “Nursing and physician staff shortages prevent hospitals from operating at full capacity. Fifty-three beds are closed at the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo, and 22 of 44 new forensic beds cannot open at the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Fort Logan. That means 75 beds are closed, meaning 249 individuals are not served per year.” In July, CMHHIP was able to open an additional 39 beds “thanks to staffi ng ini- tiatives” that will “allow the state to serve approximately 129 more Coloradans per year,” Saenz notes. This, coupled with extra staffi ng, is something that CDHS offi cials hope will alleviate the pain being felt across the state by DAs and the courts. But mental health experts say it’s still not enough. “Even if we had all the staff that we need at the state hospital in Pueblo, we would still need more beds,” Johnson says. “There’s still a huge bed shortage.” According to Saenz, the state hospital and OCFMH have been unable to comply with the 2019 consent decree because both have been focused on solving staffi ng issues. “We have been aggressively pursuing increased staffi ng levels by offering $14,000 hiring bonuses for nurses and hosting same-day hiring events,” she says. “With an initial $7,000 bonus (from September 2022 through February 2023), the mental health hospitals hired an average of 2.6 nurses per month. With the $14,000 bonus, the hospitals hired about 8.7 nurses per month.” For many people — including Sheriff Diggins and several DAs — the bonuses aren’t enough, and they suggest that the state seems to be nickel-and-diming its CMHHIP employees until the delays just somehow go away on their own. “They’ve tried to get creative and come up with some hiring incentives, monetary incentives to bring in new staff,” says Kell- ner. “That’s all well and good, and it should happen. But this is a problem that’s been going on.” The issues with delays and backups have been grabbing headlines since 2011, when the nonprofi t group Disability Law Colorado sued CDHS over the state hospital’s mount- ing problems. The two parties eventually reached a settlement, which led to the 2019 consent decree. With counties having to compete against the private sector for staffers, Diggins says it’s been hard to keep up with what the outside world is paying. “When they’re paying top dollar for things and you don’t have to work in this [jail] environment, that’s an easy equation for folks who aren’t dedicated to actually doing this work,” he says. “What we need to do is fi gure out how we can add to the work that’s being done by paying people what they’re worth. Are there ways that grant dollars or perhaps incentives from the state could help local jurisdictions attract more people to be able to do this work?” One possible solution presented by sev- eral DAs and sheriffs is to fi nd a way to end the 2019 consent decree fi nes and reallocate that $10 million to $12 million that state hospital delays are costing each year. “The idea that the state — the taxpay- ers — are paying around $12 million in fi nes every single year because of this problem, with no end in sight, it’s absolutely unac- ceptable,” Kellner says. “I appreciate that they’re trying to hire more folks, but if we can fi nd apparently $12 million to pay a fi ne, why can’t we put that kind of money into the state hospital system?” “Instead of spending money on salaries for providers,” Kelly notes, “they continue to pay massive penalties for their complete fail- ure to abide by Colorado statutory deadlines. CMHHIP has been able to brazenly ignore statutory deadlines for years while failing to provide any reasonable explanation for why the leadership has not been able to solve the alleged staffi ng shortage issue.” Adds Allen, “The fi nes levied by the fed- eral court highlight exactly how impactful this crisis has become, and the dollars paid in fi nes would have been much better spent on improving staffi ng and response times.” DA McCann points out that the millions of dollars in fi nes is money that can be ac- cessed for treatments and procedures for mental health. “Anyone can apply to get funding from the fines committee,” she says. “So I think it’s actually not a bad thing that [the money] is being made available. ... I think Denver’s used some of it to purchase a motel that they’re renovating. DA’s offi ces can apply, and even service providers.” Mason remains skeptical, however. “Where does that money go?” he asks. “I don’t know where those fi nes are going. I don’t have any fi rsthand knowledge of that. There is no question that the state hospital’s failures are impacting the Colorado taxpayer in a negative way — there’s just no question about it. “When you have a homicide case that is delayed for years — plural, years— that costs the taxpayer signifi cantly more money,” Ma- son charges. “It costs money in resources for the district attorney’s offi ce, it costs money in resources for the court, it costs money in resources for the public defender’s offi ce. And that is, without question, one of the many consequences of [the state hospital’s] inability to process these cases quickly.” James Karbach, director of legislative policy and external communications for the Offi ce of the State Public Defender, believes nothing will change until Coloradans realize that mental health is a serious problem in this state — and not just for criminal offenders. “Despite a federal lawsuit and a crisis this state has known about for eleven years, it appears that — at some level — the state is deliberately indifferent in addressing mental health progress and is instead comfortable with the current situation,” Karbach says. Colorado is currently ranked 49th in mental health funding, he notes. “Forget competency,” Karbach says. “Let’s talk about legit mental health care. We have a crisis but keep fi nding money to keep people in jail. ... We have been told that licensing and regulation of the hospitals require a certain level of staffi ng and that there is not adequate staffi ng. The explana- tion is the state cannot fi ll vacant positions. We have been told that COVID caused the current explosion of the waiting list. We have been told there are not enough beds. We also have been told the number of people who are incompetent is growing. And while the current and most cited excuse for the wait list is lack of staffi ng, all of these excuses have been repeated over the last eleven years since the lawsuit to constitutionally challenge the system was fi led. We are worse off as a state than we were when a federal court fi rst found this backlog was a wide-scale constitutional violation of a person’s rights. “The truth is our state is among the worst in funding the mental health and behavioral health system outside of the criminal legal process. We do a terrible job at providing resources and treatment that could prevent entry into the criminal legal system. We do a terrible job implementing solutions that are supported by the research.” If there’s anyone who serves as proof of Colorado’s failing mental health system — and the need to make statewide legislative changes — it’s Cole Priest. The Boulder County man — who is ac- cused of attacking and detaining a thirteen- year-old girl against her will as she was walking home from school — was arrested in September and found to have a prior case from 2018 resulting in misdemeanor Helpless and Hopeless continued from page 8 Call Elaine Lustig, PhD .......................................................... at 303-369-7770 Needing Your Emotional ....... Animal W/ You? For eligible people who need their emotional support animal to accompany them at/or away from home, I am available to provide the documentation and counseling. CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED www.innerbeatyoga.com YOUR GROOVE