6 OCTOBER 5-11, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | general housing, it’s tough. But so far, so good. He hasn’t acted out. I don’t know if he’s on medication or what, but so far, he hasn’t done anything to get him down in holding.” In 2021, Colorado legislators passed a law that restricts holding inmates with a diag- nosed mental illness in solitary confi nement or “restrictive housing,” where someone is kept alone for up to 24 hours a day. The law went into effect on July 1 that year and applies to jails with more than 400 beds. As a result, people who are in need of inpatient competency services — and aren’t supposed to be in jail in the fi rst place — are forced to deal with their mental problems alongside “some real hard-core people,” says Sheriff Jackson, which makes everyone act out and things harder for deputies to control. “These [deputies] get called names, they get mistreated verbally, and it’s very dif- fi cult for them,” Jackson explains. “Out of my deputies, six of them are in the police academy, working in the jails as detention offi cers, but they’re wanting to get out. And their way out of it is to go to the police acad- emy and get a job on patrol, either with my patrol division or the city.” District Attorney Brian Mason of the 17th Judicial District, which covers Adams County and Broomfi eld, notes how “jail is not supposed to be a mental health treat- ment facility” but often is for many judicial districts. “While there can be services offered, the primary focus of [a jail] is not to be a local or mini-state hospital,” he says. Dr. Nikki Johnson, chief of mental health services for the Denver Sheriff Department, tells Westword that her department is cur- rently considered the largest psychiatric provider in the city and the second-largest psy- chiatric provider in the entire state, followed by the Colorado Department of Corrections. Inmates who are found incompetent “should be in a hospital setting, where they can get those services, but those beds do not exist,” Johnson says. Although problems at the state hospital have impacted Colorado’s justice system for over a decade, the initial issues focused on court delays and a lack of staffi ng. However, DAs from seven different judicial districts — as well as mental health professionals, the Offi ce of the State Public Defender and sher- iffs in three counties — say that there’s much more involved, and that it’s time for people, including legislators, to fi nally take notice. “We’re seeing some of the longest delays that I’ve ever seen in my career, and I’ve been working at the DA’s offi ce for almost seven- teen years now,” Mason says. “There are 22 judicial districts in the state of Colorado. The state hospital’s ineffi ciency and inability to do its job is impacting every single judicial district in the state. And we, as a collective group of elected district attorneys, are all concerned about this.” It’s hard to miss the casualties of the state hospital debacle. Homicide cases sitting on dockets “for months and months and months,” according to Denver DA Beth McCann; victims’ families calling repeat- edly and going to seemingly endless court proceedings in search of answers; mentally incompetent offenders stuck inside county jails without getting the help they need. High-profi le cases such as the Boulder King Soopers shooting and the Gannon Stauch killing in Colorado Springs have caught more attention as they languish in their respective districts and drag on because of various delays and overcrowding issues at the state hospital. But the low-level and lesser-known offenders actually often suffer most, according to legal experts and mental health professionals. This is because inmates typically remain behind bars until they are restored to competency or are found to be incompetent to stand trial, with many serv- ing maximum jail sentences for their alleged crimes as a result of “timing out” — being released once the longest possible sentence is reached. State law prevents any inmate from be- ing kept in custody awaiting treatment for a longer period than the maximum sentence they would have received and served, which in the case of low-level offenders usually isn’t determined by the DA’s offi ce or judges. “It’s rare that you see somebody charged with a misdemeanor serve the maximum sentence,” says DA John Kellner of the 18th Judicial District, which covers Arapahoe, Douglas, Elbert and Lincoln counties. “Most cases are resolved with a plea agreement, which means a plea is something that’s going to avoid the maximum possible sentence. So you can have people who are struggling with mental illness, who are found to be incompe- tent — waiting to have restoration services [at the state hospital] — be held in custody for the maximum amount of time possible, when if they had access to those restoration services and were able to participate in their own case, they probably would have been released much earlier. And, frankly, could have had probation services or services that would continue on and try to make sure that [the offender] stays on track.” According to Thain Bell, chief deputy district attorney and head of the behavioral health unit of the Denver District Attorney’s Offi ce, “releasing these people with nothing is the worst-case scenario.” Others agree. “Ultimately, if you’ve got a defendant who’s sitting in custody longer or as long as that sentence could be for their case — or even after a year of getting evaluations for somebody who’s not competent [and] can’t be restored — we’re just going to dismiss those cases?” Kellner asks. “We’re not able to actually get people treated or attempt to restore them to competency before a clock runs out? Now, that’s wrong. That’s unfair to everybody in the justice system.” According to Bell, individuals who time out and are released without receiving care and mental health services are “more likely to reof- fend in that situation than the alternatives.” Before trial, if defendants are found to not understand the court system, the charges against them or their basic legal rights, they (or their legal counsel) are legally allowed to raise the issue of competency. A judge will typically order an evaluation to be performed by trained psychiatrists or psychologists at the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo or Fort Logan in Denver, where the state’s other mental health services are located. When the issue of competency is raised in a case, the prosecution is suspended indefi - nitely until the defendant can be evaluated and treated, according to state prosecutors. These delays have caused “a tremendous impact on the justice system and our com- munities,” says DA Michael Dougherty of the 20th Judicial District, which was able to fi nally restore alleged King Soopers shooter Ahmad Al Aliwi Al-Issa to competency this year after numerous failed attempts to get him evaluated and into the state hospital. “Our offi ce strongly opposed another evaluation based on the number of evalu- ations and reports provided to the court throughout the past two years, his improve- ment over the past several months, and the fact that we were already set for a restoration hearing,” Dougherty says. “The victim fami- lies were grateful for the judge’s decision, because the delays cause them to become outraged, frustrated and exhausted. As I stated in court, this case and its issues are consistent with the other cases caught up in the state hospital process.” When defendants are locked up in jail for an extended period of time instead of being treated and seen by state doctors, it can have a drastic effect on both their mental and physical health, according to DAs and mental health experts. “They are suffering and deteriorating without care, and all the while, victims are left waiting for the case to move forward,” Dougherty says. “The jails become backed up with these people who are supposed to be at the state hospital, and jail staff are left trying to care for them.” In Boulder, overcrowding at the county jail — which was built to house 275 inmates and currently has around 460 — has created a “signifi cant issue for the safety and well- being of inmates, staff and our community,” notes Dougherty. “Due to the crowding, the jail encourages police offi cers to write tickets instead of make arrests, which can hurt community safety,” he adds. Stephen Redfearn, deputy chief of opera- tions for the Boulder Police Department, tells Westword that the ticket-fi rst policy was put in place in response to “restrictions on what types of criminal violations the jail will take,” under a new order from the Boulder County Jail. “We are not always privy to the reasons behind why the Boulder County Jail is not accepting some arrests, but we have been informed that some of the reasons for the ar- rest restrictions are due to a backlog of people waiting to go to the state hospital,” Redfearn confi rms. “We are no longer able to take some people to jail, and thus we don’t have as many tools in our possession to disrupt someone’s criminal behavior. At times, writing someone repeated tickets does not have the same im- pact as a physical arrest and may not deter people from committing crimes.” Sheriff Johnson says that the arrest standards have been set “for all of the law enforcement agencies in Boulder County,” which ultimately determine who will be accepted at the jail. “If a case does not meet the arrest standards, the person can be is- sued a ticket or booked and released from the jail,” he explains. “This is solely due to the capacity issues we face.” According to Johnson and Dougherty, one of the biggest challenges the county faces is freeing up space at the jail. “We are at capacity due to the number of violent and/or severely mentally ill inmates we have in the jail today,” says Johnson. “There are 48 individuals who must be housed alone in our jail, which means there are 96 beds that cannot be used by someone else. If the criminal cases for the 53 people we have awaiting restoration could move forward, that would help alleviate the crowd- ing in our jail.” To make matters worse, Johnson says, “there have been assaults on deputies and mental health staff that include physical attacks as well as getting spit on.” He and his staff feel “helpless in these situations, as what they need is treatment, not isolation, for up to a year waiting for admission.” Freeing up jail beds currently occupied by people who should be at the state hospital would not only give the sheriff’s offi ce more room to house criminals, it would also lead to more arrests and better security in the work- place, Dougherty argues. “Those beds could be put to use by law enforcement in Boulder County in ensuring public safety by making arrests when appropriate instead of being encouraged to simply write tickets,” he says. Colorado’s hospital backlog has become such a problem that in 2019, a federal court issued a consent decree in favor of creat- ing a fi ne that Coloradans must pay when the state fails to meet Helpless and Hopeless continued from page 5 continued on page 8 EL PASO COUNT Y SHERIFF’S OFFICE Ahmad Al Aliwi Alissa and Letecia Stauch were both found competent to stand trial. BOULDER POLICE DEPARTMENT