8 OCTOBER 5-11, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | standards. “The taxpayers of Colorado have been paying that fi ne ever since,” Dougherty explains. “It is $10 million to $12 million per year that should be in the pocket of the taxpayers or used for better purposes.” All seven of the DAs who spoke with Westword agree: The number of competency evaluations is higher than ever before; delays at the hospitals are the worst they’ve ever seen; and mentally unstable and incompe- tent offenders are being released back into society without receiving help that they’ve been ordered to receive. “We need a solution to this problem,” says Mason. “It can’t keep going on like it is now. It’s hurting the state, it’s hurting victims, it’s hurting defendants. We need to make this a priority, and the state really needs to fi nd a solution to this problem.” Letecia Stauch — a Colorado Springs woman convicted of stabbing, beating and shoot- ing her eleven-year-old stepson to death in 2020 — is a classic example of cases being “dramatically and directly impacted” by the continued delays in the state hospital system and why in-house solutions are ultimately needed across the board, according to DA Michael Allen of the 4th Judicial District. “The defendant waited months to have a competency evaluation completed, and then that same issue arose when the defendant’s sanity was called into question by the defense team,” he says. “The delays caused emotional and unfortunate impacts on the victims in the case. Instead of grieving over the mur- der of their eleven-year-old son, they were continually frustrated by delays caused by the evaluation process. And they were left to feel as though their loss was less signifi cant.” The 4th Judicial District, which covers El Paso and Teller counties, has a separate competency docket to manage the growing numbers of cases “created by the delays” and complete evaluations in a “timelier manner,” Allen says. “We have seen such a dramatic backlog of cases in the 4th Judicial District that it required stakeholders to come together to create a workable competency docket,” he explains. “We had to fi nd a solution for those cases that are languishing in the void created by the failure of the state hospital to provide timely competency evaluations. “Competency dockets are time and em- ployee resource-intensive,” he continues, “and they undoubtedly impact the costs incurred by Colorado taxpayers. The most dramatic delays occur in high-level cases, such as what we worked through in the Stauch prosecution, but all level of cases are being affected. These delays impact criminal defendants at all levels as their cases lan- guish, and on victims who are re-victimized in the process.” In Denver, the DA’s offi ce and Sheriff Elias Diggins are attempting to tackle the hospital crisis head-on with a “people-fi rst approach,” according to Diggins, which is aimed at get- ting inmates the help they need while they’re waiting to go to Pueblo or Fort Logan. This means providing self-restoration programs and competency evaluations for people locked up at both the Denver County Jail and the Downtown Detention Center. “I don’t think it’s just the state’s respon- sibility; I think it’s all of our responsibility,” Diggins says. “We can help the state if we can stand these programs up in each of our jurisdictions, because the problem belongs to everyone, not just the State of Colorado. So Denver County can help Arapahoe County can help Adams County. Every single county has this challenge in their jails. So if we all work toward it together, then we can have a much greater impact.” In Arapahoe County, the DA’s offi ce has started doing whatever it can to get prisoners looked at by evaluators as soon as the issue of competency is raised. “These evaluations are literally occurring at times through the food slot — right in a jail cell,” DA Kellner says. “And that’s because of what’s going on [at the state hospital].” According to McCann, Denver has been taking “innovative approaches” to getting inmates the help they need while they wait for a state hospital bed, including creating a competency court — known as REACH Court — within the Denver District Court system, which handles felony competency cases and “tries to fi gure out how best to handle them, and how to perhaps get [in- mates] into services prior to a fi nding of competency,” says the DA. “This docket is aimed at addressing inad- equacies in the mental health system, with the main goal being to fi nd alternatives to incarceration for persons going through the competency process,” says the Den- ver District Attorney’s Offi ce in an online description. “The success of this program relies on the cooperation and collaboration of essential criminal justice and community organizations including the District Attor- ney, Public Defender, City Attorney, Probate Court, Sheriffs Department, Guardian Ad Litems, Pretrial Services, Wellpower, Offi ce of Behavioral Health, Brain Injury Alliance and local treatment providers.” The 8th Judicial District, which covers Larimer and Jackson counties, created a competency docket to provide access to resources for defendants with mental health needs, to “safely supervise” those who are out of custody waiting on the state, and to “ensure the criminal justice system can keep moving forward,” according to DA Gordon P. McLaughlin. In Boulder, county offi cials are “break- ing ground” on an Alternative Sentencing Facility, which will “provide more space and treatment programs for individuals in custody at the jail,” Dougherty says. “This is a very innovative, positive step, and one of the reasons that I am hopeful and excited for Boulder County.” Creating self-restoration programs and separate competency dockets — something the 18th District has also done, according to Kellner — is an aim of many Colorado jurisdictions these days. Other programs and services that Denver County has imple- mented include a Restoration Treatment Unit, a “competency diversion program” and Court Ordered Assertive Care Treat- ment, or COACT. Denver’s competency diversion program is used to identify defendants who have pre- viously been found incompetent on lower- level offense charges and then tries to get them connected to resources immediately — ultimately keeping them out of the crimi- nal justice system altogether, according to Chief Deputy DA Bell. The COACT program is “designed for people who are certifi able” and “can get a civil commitment,” he says. “We’re trying to route these people out of the criminal justice system and into the probate courts, where they can focus on their treatment,” Bell explains. People who qualify for the district’s competency diversion program must have non-violent records and “eligible charges,” according to the DA’s offi ce and sheriff de- partment. “We’re obviously not going to admit someone for competency diversion who commits an aggravated robbery with a gun,” Bell says. “But for lower-level offenses, if you’ve been previously found incompetent, you will be eligible to be screened. And then they do an initial evaluation to determine if you’re likely still incompetent — and then you’re eligible, basically.” The main purpose of the diversion pro- gram is to free up space in jail and the state hospital by preventing mentally ill individu- als from “ever getting in the system,” Bell says. “We know where the case is going to go if we don’t.” According to DA McCann, cases in Denver are often dismissed so that the defendants can “go through the process of services without them clogging up the criminal system.” Bell says that the approach Denver is tak- ing with REACH should be implemented across Colorado. “Instead of waiting for them to time out, we’re trying to identify people who are going to time out prior to that and trying to release them in the community and get them treatment through out-of-custody [services] while they still have a pending case,” Bell explains. “And then if they get in compliance with their treatment, we’ll end up dismissing the case anyway — because we know that’s where we’re going. But instead of just releasing them from the jail, hopefully we’re getting connected to services and in treatment situations so they won’t re-offend.” Diggins says he believes that “leading with humanity” and compassion is some- thing that can go a long way to mitigating the state hospital challenge, while also providing specifi c services for people who are affected. “We have what we call in the church a ‘dual mindset,’ and the fi rst half of that is we lead with our humanity,” Diggins says. “The second is the deprivation of a person’s freedom is their punishment. So I was actu- ally given that vision by God before I became the sheriff. So as we, as a department, have made that a part of the fabric of what we do and who we are, you will fi nd that the Denver Sheriff Department — all members of our department — believe that and understand that that’s a part of what we do.” According to Diggins, the sheriff de- partment currently has twelve beds as part of its Restoration Treatment Unit, which is completely separate from the main jail population and is intended to treat, restore and re-enter inmates into the criminal justice system. It will soon be adding six more beds following a September 18 vote by Denver City Council. “It was passed unanimously,” Diggins says. “We have tremendous support from the Denver City Council and the mayor’s offi ce, as well. Everyone in the city of Denver — the DA, the public defenders, the police, the sheriffs, the Department of Safety — everybody un- derstands how important this program is. So that went through without any discussion.” But Sheriff Jackson notes how smaller communities, such as those in the 12th Dis- trict, just don’t have the resources or mon- etary support that places like Denver do. “We lack in funding,” Jackson says. “We just do not have the funding — we just don’t. Most of that is based on property taxes.” In the 17th Judicial District, it took more than fi ve years to resolve one of the jurisdiction’s most gruesome murder cases. In 2017, Emanuel Doll, a 25-year-old Broomfi eld man, lured his four-year-old nephew down to the basement of Doll’s parents’ house and killed him with an ax. He was committed to the state hospital in 2018 for treatment to stand trial, but wasn’t found not guilty by reason of insanity until 2022. “That was a horrifi c case, which got de- layed multiple years because of the state hospital,” Mason says. “This has obviously been going on for a couple years now, but I mean, at what point does this end? Do you see an end in sight for this? Do we just keep dealing with these delays?” For many district attorneys, including Mason, it’s hard to hear state hospital offi - cials complain about Helpless and Hopeless continued from page 6 continued on page 10 The Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo complains of staffi ng shortages. NORIX GROUP, INC