6 SEPTEMBER 7-13, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | that Suding couldn’t answer. So “I started knocking on doors at the history department in CU,” she says. And she found a history graduate student — Amelia Brackett, who has since graduated — to lead a historical research component of the Boulder Apple Tree Project. It turned out that most of the trees the project was identifying were among the fi rst ever planted in the area. “When people moved here, when the fi rst European people came here, you wouldn’t have seen any of these trees,” Suding says, gesturing out to the leafy land- scape of north Boulder. “None of these pine trees would be here, hardly any of the cottonwoods.” And defi nitely not the apple trees. When settlers be- gan arriving in the mid- to late 1800s, the landscape was “much more arid, so they basi- cally had to plant any of this stuff — for shade, for food. It was one of the first things they did when they tried to establish themselves,” Suding explains. Since different ap- ple trees produce dif- ferent kinds of apples — marked by their own flavors and physical characteristics — many homesteaders would bring a small branch of an apple tree from back home and plant the branch to take root as a sapling. This ensured that they could enjoy a taste of home, since most apple trees grown from seeds do not produce good-tasting fruit. By the late 1800s, Boulder was an all-out apple town and Colorado a major apple- producing state. “Chautauqua was an orchard before [it was] Chautauqua, so there’s old trees there that are really quite special,” Sud- ing says. The nearby towns of Hygiene and Lyons both had major orchard operations; a stretch of road near U.S. 36 going up toward Estes Park is even named “Apple Valley Road.” But disease, drought and then floods hit Boulder’s apple economy. Prohibition affected it, too. “A lot of the early trees were planted for alcohol,” says Suding, who notes that even trees that didn’t produce good- tasting fruit might make good hard apple cider. The tree she found near her home, for example, produces a “super-tart green apple. Almost certainly it was used for cider.” And then a certain apple took the country by storm. “There was a real push in the ’30s and ’40s to plant Red Delicious apples,” says Suding. People felt “there was one re- ally good kind of apple, and the rest of them were just no good. So a lot of orchards were cut down or replaced with those, and then we realized a decade later the Red Delicious actually doesn’t do well here.” After that, Red Delicious production moved primarily to Washington state. And Colorado’s apple production largely disappeared. “It seems like people think that if Col- orado kept with the types of apples that actually do well in this climate, a lot of the orchards that were once here maybe could have persisted. But we kind of followed the trends — Colorado State at that time was tell- ing people to cut down things. We just didn’t understand how important the diversity and the variety was,” Suding says. Development was the last nail in the cof- fi n, replacing the orchards of north Boulder with housing. “A lot of times they would cut down most of the trees, but they would leave one or two in the backyards when they were making their subdivisions and the developments in the ’40s and ’50s,” she explains. “So there’s a lot of interesting old trees in that area. “And the old trees that stayed are just kind of the lucky ones,” she continues. “They’re mostly in people’s backyards or in old or- chards that someone kept because they didn’t need [the land]. But there are trees along ca- nals here, or places where it’s pretty amazing that they can just survive. They don’t have to be taken care of; they can survive. It’s impres- sive when you see an old tree.” And distressing when you realize what’s been lost. “In the ’20s, there was a state hor- ticulturalist who went around and recorded all the trees that were planted in the different orchard districts...[and kept] really detailed records of all the different varieties,” Suding says. “It’s estimated that there were at least 400 different varieties of apples that were cultivated.” A hundred years later, she adds, “we can’t fi nd about half of them.” The very fi rst apple trees that produced fruit for human consumption came from Kazakh- stan. Nearly all modern apple tree “cultivars” can be traced back to a single ancient ances- tor from the Tian Shan Mountains, where apple trees have grown for millions of years, according to the Orchard Project, a similar initiative to the Boulder Apple Tree Project located in the United Kingdom. Animals that ate the apples from these Kazakh forests likely spread the seeds be- yond the region, and the Romans eventually discovered them in Syria. “The trees from Kazakhstan started be- ing collected and transferred along the Silk Road thousands of years ago, and then they started hybridizing with crab apples from Europe,” Suding says. “Then people started taking them to their different areas in Europe and cultivating them.” To reproduce a particular apple, you must “clone” the tree that originally produced that fruit. Apple makers do that by grafting — taking a piece of a tree and attaching it to another es- tablished tree. The grafted piece will then grow into a branch, which will produce the same kind of fruit that the original tree produced. Through grafting, one tree could produce multiple kinds of apples. To create a tree clone that produces a single kind of apple, a piece of the original tree can be grafted onto rootstock and planted as a sapling. Once established, that clone can then be cloned again. These clones are called cultivars. When a cultivar, or certain fl avor of apple, becomes popular enough, it is termed an “heirloom.” “A lot of these trees we call heirlooms, some of them can be traced back from Eu- rope, but the majority are from North Amer- ica,” Suding points out. “Red Delicious was found in the Ozarks just randomly on some hill, and someone said, ‘Oh, that one’s good.’ And so that one gets grafted.” New cultivars, or apple fl avors, are usually created by breeding two established cultivars. But a tree from two bred cultivars doesn’t always produce good-tasting apples. “If you plant a ton of apple seeds, probably one out of every 1,000 will be good fruit, and so that would be the one that you cultivate,” Suding says. That explains the Johnny Appleseed story. “One of the reasons there was a lot of spreading apple seeds throughout the Ohio Valley was basically to fi nd the one in a million tree that was good,” she explains. “There’s a lot of bad apples.” But the good ones are worth keeping — and taking on long journeys. “Immigrants from, let’s say, Northern Europe had favorite trees. That was how they made their applesauce or their cider or something like that. And so it was likely that they would bring their varieties into their homesteads,” Suding says. By tracing the genetic history of a culti- var, or by fi nding where an apple tree has a genetic match, “you can kind of follow people,” she adds. “There’s something about these old trees — they have so many of these stories, and there’s a lot of ways that people identify with them. There’s this sense of place. They’re the trees that are a part of Boulder or Colorado.” To preserve those trees and that history, the Boulder Apple Tree Project cuts a piece of each new tree it locates in order to graft it. “We have one tree that we gathered from Eldorado,” says Amy Dunbar-Wallis, a CU Boulder graduate student who works on the project. “And it’s a really fascinating tree because it has a couple of crosstown matches here in Boulder, but it also matches a tree down in Fort Lewis, and it also matches a tree in Wyoming and a tree in Montana. So we think, from digging through some historic records, we think that it came from a project at the University of Minnesota; they were looking for cold-tolerant type trees. But it was likely a project that never made it to market.” The University of Minnesota has been breeding and researching apples since the late 1800s. But while the Boulder Apple Tree Project has found genetic matches for clones of this tree, it has not been able to fi nd a spe- cifi c match in those fi les or among any of the named or known apple tree cultivars in a da- tabase kept by the United States Department of Agriculture. “Maybe it was never named,” speculates Dunbar-Wallis. “It could have been named, but we haven’t found a name for it. But we do know it has matches and it was spread out in some places. We know the parent identity of the trees are Grimes Golden and Wealthy. A cross of those parents was found in records from Minnesota. ... We can’t be certain that our tree is from that particu- lar breeding program, Pome on the Range continued from page 5 continued on page 8 Amy Dunbar-Wallis stands by a recently planted apple tree in the orchard she oversees; Katharine Suding by the old apple tree that inspired the Boulder Apple Tree Project. EVAN SEMÓN