8 SEPTEMBER 7-13, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | but it could be likely.” And how did it get to Boulder County? “What’s likely is the homesteaders knew somebody who said, ‘Hey, I’ve got this tree. Want to try it out?’” she suggests. James Luby is a professor at the University of Minnesota and one of the leaders of the school’s apple-breeding program — where Dunbar-Wallis believes the Eldorado tree came from. “Both Wealthy and Grimes Golden were very popular varieties back in the late 1800s, early 1900s,” Luby says, noting that the Wealthy cultivar was actually created in Minnesota and used often in the university’s breeding program. “Wealthy — it was like a superstar variety of its time and recognized as being quite winter-hardy...so it would have been known as something that might succeed [out west]. So then you send some seeds out to, you know, your former neighbor, your brother or sister who moved out there, and they take off.” Another Boulder Apple Tree Project tree, which Dunbar-Wallis identifi es as “498,” was also found near Eldorado, on land that’s been in the Pruden family for four generations. “We connect with historians and local historical societies, and they’re able to tell us about the families and where those families came from,” says Dunbar-Wallis. According to the CU Boulder Museum of Natural History, Jennie Margaret Hogan Pruden came to Boulder in 1882 and kept a detailed diary of her life from 1891 to 1946. The family built a house on property in south Boul- der in 1891; between 1891 and 1898, Margaret and her husband, Charlie Pruden, planted 115 trees. The apples “were generally small — not bad-tasting, but not delicious,” grandaughter Cherry Moore told the museum. “I mean, they weren’t premium apples. With the exception, there was one tree out there. It was kind of like the tree in the Garden of Eden. It was a Golden Apple, and it sat right out there. And it was everyone’s favorite.” Like Moore, many people are happy to share history. “People are really interested,” Suding says. “They have a tree. It’s going to die soon, but they love that tree. ‘This was my grandma’s tree; she made applesauce.’ There’s a lot of interest, because people are attached to these old trees. But these [new ones] kind of carry on, because they’re the same tree.” As Suding’s small team of researchers began cataloguing apple trees, they soon realized how big the job would be. “All of a sudden it was totally clear that these are not just limited, unusual cases. They are all over the place,” she says. “After 2017, we realized that there were far more trees than a couple of people can go sample.” So in 2018, the Boulder Apple Tree Proj- ect started what it called the “Apple Blitz.” The blitz takes place every fall and involves researchers and community volunteers go- ing out to hunt for more lost apple trees. “We send all these teams out to record and try to tag and do as much as we can to document all these trees,” Suding explains. In 2019, CU Boulder began offering an undergraduate science course — EBIO 1250: Introduction to Research — that works with the Boulder Apple Tree Project, and the blitz is one of the fi rst big events of the semester. “The students love it because they’re kind of like the experts,” she says. “And the com- munity is really interested because...a lot of people want to know about particular trees.” Boulder resident Carol Taylor invited the Boulder Apple Tree Project to check out her apple tree during the 2021 blitz. “When I heard about the Apple Tree Project, I was like, ‘Oh! I need to fi nd out more about my tree and where it came from,’” she recalls. Taylor lives just north of Chautauqua Park and thinks that her tree is at least sixty years old based on the age of her house. CU Boulder students and a project staff member “came over, and they all looked at the tree [and] took notes,” she recalls. “The tree had a lot of apples at the time, so we took some apples; they cut [them] up and took some seeds. They all tasted the apples, and they had a little chart about the fl avor of the apple and the texture, so they recorded all of that.” She adds that the apples are “absolutely just delicious. They’re a little bit tart and crunchy.” “This is a quite tall tree at over 30 feet tall and a large canopy of ~23 feet!” Dunbar- Wallis notes today. “At the time of tagging, this tree had abundant green/red fruits that were considered quite tart to the taste.” Before the researchers left, they nailed a small silver plaque to the trunk: “Boulder Apple Tree Project // 513.” Taylor’s tree has not yet been “DNA fi n- gerprinted,” according to Dunbar-Wallis, but the project has “dried leaf material for when we are able to pick that up again.” CU faculty member Lisa Corwin teaches the class, which gives students a chance to do fun, important scientifi c work early in their education, as opposed to the slightly less ex- citing and more standard scientifi c education that undergraduates usually receive. “It’s a type of class that we call a course-based undergraduate research experience,” Sud- ing says. “The premise is that if you only do cookbook stuff when you learn about science, and the answer is already known and you just have to [follow a] list and see if you get the right or wrong answer — all that interest about having a question that you want to fi gure out and be creative and stuff like that, you kind of lose that in biology until you’re almost done with your degree. “So starting early and saying, ‘Actually, we don’t know about these apple trees; let’s fi gure it out,’ you get to have an authentic research [experience] right from the start,” she says. “It’s the idea that that could be fi rst, and we can give you lectures and teach you about how photosynthesis works later. But it’s that discovery — that’s the thing to start with.” The project also works with other col- leges and community colleges throughout the state, including Front Range Community College and Fort Lewis College. As the Boulder Apple Tree Project grew from mapping and cataloguing trees to clon- ing and preserving trees, it needed room to grow. While it stores all of its grafted and cloned trees in a greenhouse, Suding and her team thought it was time for the project to have an orchard of its own. Last year, it found just the place for it: a little triangle of land in north Boulder just off of CO 119 owned by Boulder County Parks & Open Space. “This is an agricultural lease, but it’s a re- ally small piece of property, so it’s not likely that someone’s going to want to put a farm in here,” says Dunbar-Wallis. “But Boulder County Open Space wanted the land to be used, and we’ve been working with them since 2018, and they thought it would be a great way to bring in all these trees.” “I think it’s a really cool project,” says Mary Tiernan, an arborist for Boulder County Parks & Open Space. “We’ve been acting as facilitators to get them access to trees that they otherwise wouldn’t have been able to access. They’re really awesome people to work with... full of cool little tidbits about the trees.” Dunbar-Wallis and other project mem- bers surveyed the orchard land last fall. “For a long time, this was prairie dog habitat, and last year, Open Space relocated all the prairie dogs,” she says, adding that at that point, “it was mostly dirt.” The project planted grafted tree saplings on the land on May 1, when it “was still mostly dirt,” says Dunbar-Wallis. But then came all the summer rain, and because “the ground had been tilled so much by the prairie dogs, everything grew up, and this space worked really hard at being a wetland. So for about a month, we had lots of toads, we had lots of redwing blackbirds nesting.” And grass, “grass up to our shoulders” that was taller than the baby trees, she adds. Boulder Open Space mowed the grass, but it wasn’t easy. “We had put cages around each of the trees, and we had a map that we gave to Open Space so they knew exactly where all the trees were,” Dunbar-Wallis says. “That was really scary, actually.” Now, despite some minor issues with insects and weeds and one more major in- cident involving deer breaking in and eating the tops of some specimens (Dunbar-Wallis quickly replaced them with backups from the greenhouse), the trees are in great shape. “I would say the trees have doubled in size since May 1,” Dunbar-Wallis reports. While the trees won’t bear fruit for at least a couple of years, the Boulder Apple Tree Project team hopes to eventually turn the orchard into an open and interactive educational opportunity for students and community members alike. “We want this to be a highly accessible orchard space so that folks from differ- ent situations are able to access the trees,” Dunbar-Wallis says. “Folks will be able to learn about their local food source; they’ll be able to learn about grafting; they’ll be able to learn about genetics of trees, local and native wildfl owers. This is going to be an outdoor Pome on the Range continued from page 6 Amy Dunbar-Wallis and Katharine Suding work with CU students at the Boulder Apple Tree Project orchard, where an apple tree cutting has been grafted to rootstock. BENJAMIN NEUFELD