15 AUGUST 31-SEPTEMBER 6, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | CONTENTS | LETTERS | NIGHT+DAY | CULTURE | CAFE | MUSIC | The Sweetest Thing WE VISITED SIX OF DENVER’S BEST ICE CREAM SHOPS — IN ONE DAY. BY ASHLEE REDGER Denver is positively fl ush with fantastic ice cream, and now is the time to get your last licks in before Labor Day weekend, aka the unoffi cial end of summer. Now more than ever, frozen-treat fans have their pick of styles and venues. Want soft serve? Visit Dang. What about Thai rolled ice cream (aka fried ice)? Try Milkroll Creamery on East Colfax Avenue. You can even taste ice cream that’s fl ash-frozen with nitrogen if you can catch Polar Bros. Nitro Ice Cream at events and food truck fairs around the city. But when all you want is a classic scoop, the options can be almost overwhelming. How do you decide which shop to visit when the city is rainbow-sprinkled with choices? I’m an ice cream enthusiast. Despite be- ing somewhat lactose intolerant, I always have a pint or two on backup in my freezer (usually dairy-free varieties, admittedly), and I’ve been known to plan dates and dinners with friends around where we can get ice cream afterward. Instead of taking on the not-very-realistic mission of trying to rank every ice cream shop in the metro area, I schemed a different plan: Compile a list of a few standouts and chart a path between them for an afternoon ice cream tour. “It’ll be easy,” I thought to myself. Surprise! It wasn’t easy at all. After gather- ing a list of about two dozen potential stops and anxiously laboring over which ones to pri- oritize, I had to put a few stipulations in place. First, the tour needed to focus on tradi- tionally churned scoops. Shops also needed to have a brick-and-mortar location (which, sadly, excluded the Pint’s Peak truck, one of my personal favorites). Lastly, the places needed to be within central Denver, meaning locations like Scrumptious in Arvada would have to wait. Even after narrowing it down, my list was long, and I’d be pushing my already shaky lactose tolerance to its limits. An especially tough call was which Little Man concept to visit, if any. But wait! Before you send me hate DMs: I de-prioritized the Little Man locations only because they could easily have a whole magical tour of their own. In the end, I set fi ve must-hit stops and had another eight bonus ones...just in case. I knew I couldn’t do it alone, especially if I wanted to try a wider variety of fl avors from each stop. I needed help from someone who knows the local ice cream scene in and out. That’s where my friend and — more impor- tant — ice cream expert Michael Kimball came in. Kimball is the founder of Sadboy Creamery, which launched in June and is quickly becoming one of the hottest (or coldest?) additions to the local ice cream community. Sadboy offers nostalgia-inspired pints for pickup in Capitol Hill ev- ery Saturday. Since its launch, Kimball has dished out fl avors like Gummy Shark Creamsicle (a combo of Alphonso mango and blue raspberry sherbet, marshmallow fl uff and vanilla ice cream) and brownie chunk- laden Frownies à la Mode. I sent him a text, explained my plan, and he was in. Now we just had one more question to answer: cup or cone? First Taste: Sadboy Creamery sadboycreamery.com Off-brand Lactaid in hand, I met up with Kimball at Denver Central Market. After a veggie-filled meal from Lunchboxx to prepare ourselves for the hours of dairy to come, we dove into our fi rst ice cream taste of the day: a Sadboy sample that Kimball had brought in an insulated canteen. The fl avor, Dirty Earl, had big chunks of Oreo studded throughout an Earl Grey tea- and amaretto-infused base. It felt just as craveable as the classic cookies-and-cream combo, but made sophisticated with a bal- anced hit of fl oral fruitiness from the berga- mot in the tea. I had to restrain myself from going back for a fi fth and sixth bite. While it wasn’t part of our offi cial tour, it made for a pretty outstanding start. Stop One: High Point Creamery 2669 Larimer Street (inside Denver Central Market); there are also locations in Hilltop and Berkeley 720-805-0077 highpointcreamery.com Good for people who love chef-driven fl avors and fun seasonal options We strolled over to the cheery High Point Creamery outpost in the corner of the mar- ket and considered the options. It was one of the original vendors inside the food hall when it opened in 2016. At the time, it was the second location for husband-and-wife team Chad Stutz and Erika Thomas, who are also behind the hybrid cafe/ice cream shop Eiskaffee. While the latter focuses on German and other European treats, High Point offers a broader selection of rotating seasonal and artisan fl avors like Tin Cup Whiskey With Pistachio Brittle and Basil With Blackberry Swirl. I got a taste of the delicate Lavender Lem- onade Sorbet, but ultimately went with the fi rst fl avor that caught my eye: Cornbread With Strawberry Jam. I’m a sucker for corn- based desserts, and this one was packed with crumbly Southern-style cornbread and a sub- tle fruity ribbon. I wished I had gotten a scoop with a touch more strawberry, but overall it was summery and not too sweet. Kimball, I quickly discovered, is a pro at ordering, often picking out fl avors I overlooked. This time, he selected Orange Dreamsicle, which had a delightful vanilla-y marshmallow fl avor and chunks of actual orange popsicles folded in. It was so good, we ended up comparing almost every subsequent scoop to it. Stop Two: Nuggs Ice Cream 5135 East Colfax Avenue 720-465-9473 nuggsicecream.com Good for out-of-town visitors, patio-season hangouts and small groups or families Nuggs was founded in 2014 by Chris and Nick O’Sullivan (the siblings behind Broth- ers BBQ) and has become a favorite for neighborhood locals. It was crowned Best Ice Cream Shop in Westword’s 2019 Best of Denver and voted the Readers’ Choice winner in 2022. Although it sits only a sidewalk away from busy East Colfax, it has managed to hold fast to the friendly vibe of a Midwestern ice cream parlor. The menu is full of crowd-friendly fl avors with cute names (including Rocky Mountain Road and the Golden Oreo-packed Strawberry Blonde) as well as fl oats, malts, splits and waffl e tacos. As Kimball put it, Nuggs’s specialty is “classic fl avors that feel fresh.” With that in mind, I went for an upper Midwest favorite, Blue Moon. No, it doesn’t have anything to do with the orange-garnished beer — rather, it’s a famously secret amalgamation that’s often compared to Froot Loops, or a mix of almond, citrus and raspberry. It was my fi rst time actually trying the vivid blue-dyed ice cream, and to me, it was most reminiscent of sweet, fruity bergamot. The ice cream itself was light and fl uffy, making it that much easier to eat a scoop or two without feeling like I was overindulging. Kimball got one of his Nuggs go-tos, the Queen Bee, fl avored with honey, brown sugar, amaretto extract and honey-roasted almonds. The sugar high was beginning to hit us, and our moods were good as we scraped the bottoms of our cups. Stop Three: Sweet Action 52 Broadway; there are also locations in Washington Park, Jefferson Park and Uptown 303-282-4645 sweetaction.com Good for an afternoon pick-me-up while stroll- ing Broadway or a late-night snack (all four locations are open until 11 p.m. or midnight) With a focus on local sourcing, depend- able staff wages and wind-energy-supported operations, it’s no surprise that Sweet Action has held its own since CAFE continued on page 16 FIND MORE FOOD & DRINK COVERAGE AT WESTWORD.COM/RESTAURANTS Sweet Action is known for its rotating menu of traditional and modern fl avors. ASHLEE REDGER