8 AUGUST 17-23, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | business and trusting his passion to lead him toward helping the environment — on his own terms. Inside the world of biochar, Gaspard has been called the “cowboy of carbon.” To wander into the topic of global warming and carbon sequestration is to run headlong into a lot of talk about saving the planet and considerable confl ict, perhaps inevitable as humanity faces something never faced before in recorded history. Around the country and abroad, lone individuals are trying to take on a worldwide challenge, often without much funding, without a lot of scientifi c certifi ca- tion that would allow them to proceed more quickly and profi tably, and without much public understanding or support. Most have good intentions and most labor in obscurity. Their endeavors can be heroic — even if at times they seem almost foolish. Wealthy people who want to do some- thing to alleviate the crisis like to dabble in these areas until they begin to lose too much money or can no longer use their investments as tax write- offs and fi nally acknowledge what they’re up against. In November 2021, world leaders met in Glasgow, Scotland, to address global warming. To avoid catastro- phe, they hoped to keep the earth’s temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius or 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit, but the actual rise would likely be closer to 1.7 Celsius, leading to more fl ood- ing, crop failures, devastating heat waves and species extinc- tion. Calamity is already here, both overseas and in the U.S. A 2022 study by NASA and Co- lumbia University found that 77 percent of the American West is experiencing severe to extreme drought. As the Glasgow conference unfolded, Claire Fyson, co-head of the climate policy team at Climate Analytics, told Yahoo News, “This is the critical decade we are now in. If we don’t halve emissions from now until 2030, we really start to put 1.5 degrees [Cel- sius] out of reach.” At the close of the event, U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres echoed Fyson, saying that the battle to keep “1.5 alive will be won or lost during this de- cade.” A new report, released in March by the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, sounded even more dire — stating that “humanity is on thin ice, and that ice is melting fast” while demanding lower carbon emissions and mitigating what’s already been put into the atmosphere. People across America sit in boardrooms and coffee shops arguing about the best way to address global warming and saying how much money they’ll raise to meet this goal. Some will raise a little; many will barely try. Others will run out of cash before they can get started, and others will start but soon crash. Some others, like HBO’s John Oliver, will go on television and chastise those who’ve created fi nancial instruments designed to try to lessen greenhouse gas emissions. In August 2022, the comedian mercilessly took on the issue of carbon se- questration and carbon credits. His perfor- mance raised many questions, including when did joke tellers become signifi cant commentators regarding complex scientifi c and economic matters? Carbon credits, or offsets, allow corpora- tions with the stated goal of lowering their car- bon footprint to take alternative action when they fail to meet this goal. In Europe, purchas- ing the credits from registries is mandatory, but in the U.S. it remains voluntary and the markets are unregulated. Until recently, other continents have been more aggressive in their backing of biochar for carbon sequestration strategy. The European Biochar Industry Con- sortium is predicting an annual growth rate of 70 percent in production plants until 2030, surpassing the European Commission’s cur- rent objective for industrial carbon removal. Pro Natura International has designed, funded and implemented numerous agro-ecological projects in Africa, the Americas and Asia, using biochar to fi ght climate change and strengthen food security. The African Union is developing the Great Green Wall, an 8,500-kilometer-long forestation project intended to become the world’s largest user of biochar. America is playing catch-up. “In this culture,” says Brando Crespi, founder of Pro Natura International, “things are not real unless they make money.” Things are beginning to get real. First came the August 2002 Infl ation Reduction Act, and last December Congress authorized $447 million to research and demonstrate large-scale carbon removal. Carbon credit markets are developing — amid deep turmoil. Companies can now buy these credits from registries, with the money going back to bio- char producers to help fund their operations. The corporations can then claim they’ve done their duty in fi ghting climate change. They might even tout their businesses as “carbon neutral” or “carbon negative” — without actually taking the steps to diminish their carbon footprint. The buzzword for this is “greenwashing”: looking as if you’re doing something positive when you really aren’t. Promoters have called these credits a carbon tax on a corporation. Critics have labeled them a “get out of jail card.” Gaspard refers to the offset markets as “the wild, wild West” — along with a few harsher characterizations for these registries, which he shuns. In his HBO takedown, Oliver spoke of how in 2020 JP Morgan bought $1 mil- lion worth of offsets in order to “protect” a Pennsylvania woodland known as Hawk Mountain Preserve, which wasn’t under threat of deforestation. “It was a preserve,” Oliver said, “and not called Hawk Mountain Chop Zone or Tree Murder Playground. … On some level, you probably know that carbon offsets are bullshit, both because you’re a reasonably intelligent person and because you know exactly what show you are watching right now. I don’t open my beak to squawk out good news. ... Fundamentally, we cannot offset our way out of climate change.” More seriously, The Guardian, the Ger- man weekly Die Zeit and SourceMaterial, a nonprofi t investigative journalism orga- nization, recently completed a nine-month analysis of “scientifi c studies of Verra’s rain- forest schemes.” Verra, the world’s leading registry for the $2 billion offsets market, approves three-fourths of these transactions. According to the investigation, more than “90 percent of their rainforest offset credits… are likely to be ‘phantom credits’ and do not represent genuine carbon reductions.” They could “make global heating worse” because “94 percent of the credits had no benefi t to the climate.” Three companies mentioned in the report were Gucci, Shell and Disney. Verra has rigorously disputed the investigation and defended itself against the allegations. It contends that the methods used to measure the results do not refl ect the actual impact on forests and says it’s already addressed the criticisms raised in the study. Like the registries, biochar has faced its own headwinds. In her September 2013 article published by Earth Island Journal, Rachel Smolker took direct aim at the fl edging indus- try. The piece was titled “Biochar: Black Gold or Just Another Snake Oil Scheme?,” with this subhead: “There’s little basis for claims that biochar could solve our energy, food, and climate woes.” The tone of the piece was set early on: “Biochar enthusiasts are a hopeful bunch. They claim that charred biomass will be a win for climate, a win for soils and crop yields, hence a win against hunger and poverty, and a win for renewable energy generation. They are convinced that burning ‘biomass’…could solve our energy, food, and climate woes….” While disputing that bio- char sequesters carbon or improves yields, Smolker wrote, “Biochar enthusiasts usually insist they won’t cut forests or convert ecosystems to provide burnable biomass. ... They prefer to talk about burn- ing ‘wastes and residues.’ But there is no such thing as ‘waste’ in a forest ecosystem — all is recycled, via decay, to support regeneration and regrowth….” She concluded: “No amount of biochar, no cli- mate geoengineering tricks, no technofi xes or markets or ‘private sector engagement’ or fancy carbon accounting will be a ‘win win win’ for us.” “This was a famous article within the industry, and it highlighted a lot of the issues with the industry at the time, but it overly focused on the negative aspects,” Gaspard says. “Since then, more than 15,000 peer review papers have been published that have shown the many ben- efi ts of biochar. “It’s true that there is no ‘waste’ in a natu- ral forest ecosystem, but there are no longer natural ecosystems,” he continues. “They have been mismanaged for many decades, result- ing in forests that are incredibly overgrown, insect-laden, diseased and under stress in ways that would not have occurred in natural ecosystems. The overgrowth causes fi res to oc- cur hotter than what happens in natural eco- systems, and this will sterilize the soil. If the overgrowth somehow escapes fi re and begins to die and rot, then there is so much material decomposing it will change the characteriza- tion of the soil. We need to remove most of the dead trees and overgrowth to allow the forests to regain the status of a natural ecosystem, and we need to recognize the role of fi re in a natural ecosystem to regenerate forests. “The conversion into biochar of many of the dead trees from our overburdened and mismanaged forests, the numerous charred trees left from forest fi res, and waste wood destined for landfi lls can effectively remove gigatons of carbon from the atmosphere and place that stable carbon in the soil, where it belongs.” Carbon Cowboy continued from page 6 Wood collected from the 2020 Cameron Peak fi re (left), as well as discarded pallets and other wood waste products that will be turned into biochar. BIOCHAR NOW BIOCHAR NOW