10 AUGUST 10-16, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | good guy, too. It was a shame what happened to them. Lorenzo, who went missing with them, was a good guy, also.” After that, Paison developed a “near ob- session” with missing persons cases. “She was quite young at the time,” her father remembers. “I think she really seized on that and became really interested in missing persons. ... Every young, young person has something that happens, and it makes an imprint on them.” Paison began watching police proce- durals and cop dramas, starting with Law & Order (which she still loves), then CSI: Miami (a guilty pleasure she’s embarrassed to admit), Criminal Minds (she’s seen every episode) and The Rookie (she wishes she’d started watching it sooner). Now, two and a half decades later, her favorite show is The Lincoln Lawyer — even though it’s a legal procedural. Growing up at the dawn of the internet, she spent hours combing through police reports from across the country that she found online. “It was prob- ably an unhealthy obsession for someone who was fi ve or seven years old,” she admits. “I spent many afternoons at my mom’s offi ce with access to a computer. I was looking for missing per- sons pages, report after report, page after page.” Paison soon developed “re- ally good street smarts,” her father remembers, along with “skills about how to read a room and people.” After high school, Paison bounced between Metro State University of Denver, the Uni- versity of Colorado Denver, Community College of Denver and Arapahoe Community College, looking for a place to study criminal justice. Ulti- mately, she decided not to pursue a degree; for a time, she thought she wanted to become a homicide detective, but “I was starting to see such a change in how the community was responding to law enforcement. I saw how law enforcement was changing toward the community,” she recalls. That was right after the death of Elijah McClain in Aurora in August 2019, and the murder of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police the following May. “We weren’t headed in a direction — as far as law enforcement was concerned — that I was interested in participating in,” she adds. “I wanted to be a cop in an environment where we were encouraging community po- licing, where offi cers were knowing people in their communities and it was more of a helping situation. Policing began to take a turn toward military-style policing, and I didn’t want any part of that.” But she was still interested in missing persons mysteries. The Skiba case is still unsolved. Paison has a case fi le with all of the information she collected, and she and her dad occasion- ally theorize about what happened to their friends. Although there were some doubts cast on Paul Skiba’s on-again, off-again girl- friend, Paison doesn’t think she’s a likely culprit. Instead, she points to Paul Skiba’s reported connections to drugs and gangs. “In order to pull off a triple homicide, in- cluding that of a nine-year-old, and then hiding those bodies to the degree that they’ve never been located, that requires multiple people,” Paison suggests. “And you’ve got to have some people who don’t have a conscience.” Finally, Paison decided to follow her longtime interest and open a private investigations fi rm, Dark Knight Investigations. She chose the name because she wanted something that “portrayed strength, security and sounded kind of tough,” she says, even though her father thought the Batman connection might make it sound “too comic-y.” Colorado had just ended licensing re- quirements for private investigators, and while Paison says she “was shocked and disappointed” by that move, it made it easier to set up a business. By late 2021, she was working as an in- vestigator for law fi rms, serving legal docu- ments. Even today, her primary jobs involve tracking down witnesses for legal cases or people who skip out on debt payments and doing background checks on people, compa- nies and real estate, as well as criminal and civil case research — “the basic legal stuff you would expect a private investigator to be involved in,” she says. But she was still obsessed with missing persons cases, and only a few months after opening her business, she started volunteer- ing with We Help the Missing, a national organization founded in 2014 by a Utah investigator who connects families looking for missing loved ones with volunteer private investigators in different parts of the country. We Help the Missing had never looked for a homeless person before, and when Teresa and Evie fi lled out their intake form, Paison was the private investigator signed up to help. Anthony’s case landed in her lap on New Year’s Eve 2021. At the time, she “didn’t even know if he was going to be in the state of Colorado,” she remembers. “He might have had the inten- tion to come here, but he could have been here for a year, for all I know, and ended up in Oregon.” She started by looking through databases with Anthony’s full name (his sisters asked that it not be used in this story) and birth date. Over the past thirty years, he’d bounced from Colorado to Texas and back to Colo- rado, likely to escape the hot weather. His sisters confi rmed that most of the addresses Paison had found were old, but there was one listing for a mobile home in Mineral Point, Wisconsin. Paison called the Iowa County Sheriff’s Offi ce in Wisconsin to run Anthony’s name. “I didn’t know — maybe he was still there, he’s just in jail and that’s why he’s not in touch with anyone,” she says. After the sher- iff’s department said that Anthony wasn’t a guest of the county, she reached out to the owner of the mobile home park. She had no luck there, but she did locate a former roommate of Anthony’s. Although he hadn’t seen him in years, he fi lled her in on a few details, including that Anthony suffers from mental illness and likes to drink, but hadn’t been using drugs. Oh, and one more thing: Anthony liked to frequent Charlie Brown’s, a piano bar at 980 Grant Street in Denver. “I thought, what the heck?” Paison remembers. She headed over to Charlie Brown’s and asked patrons there if they’d seen an older white guy, about six feet tall, going by the name of Anthony. “People said, ‘Well, how the hell are we supposed to help you if you don’t even know who you’re looking for?’” she recalls. “I was just hoping that someone there would know a guy named Anthony, but unfortunately, nobody did.” She followed another lead to a trailer park in the Westminster area, but that was a dead end, too. So Paison went back to basics and started looking on the Den- ver County Court website to see if Anthony had been issued any tickets or arrest warrants, “just to see if I could get simple tips on addresses to get a clue on where he was often.” When nothing came up, she decided to call the Denver Police Department. Paison had already urged Anthony’s sisters to fi le a miss- ing persons report, but Evie said that when she’d contacted the DPD, she was told that the department couldn’t look for him because he was transient, which “means they didn’t really consider him missing.” “They had been giving her a hard time already,” Paison notes. “Offi cers should not refuse to take a report based on a person’s housing status,” a DPD spokes- person tells Westword. “If there is a person who has been denied a report of a missing person, they should try to re-report and, if denied, ask to speak with a su- pervisor.” When Paison called the DPD, she learned that Anthony had been hit by a car around East Third Avenue and Santa Fe Drive the year before. According to the police report, he was all right — and at least that showed he’d recently been in the area. “I was starting to feel better,” she remembers. She kept talking to the DPD and was able to annoy a detective into a compromise. The detective told her her that if she kept his name a secret, he’ll tell her where Anthony might be. Turns out that Anthony had been cited just a few weeks earlier for overnight camp- ing at a park in Englewood. “Might be worth a shot,” the detective told her. “That seems to be an area that he hangs out in.” Paison, who works from her home in south Denver, knew that place. After hang- ing up the phone, she jumped in her car and drove the seven minutes to Cushing Park, where it was ice-cold in mid-January. “There were some very unsavory char- acters down in the park,” she admits. The fi rst guy she approached offered her crack. “Oh, God, I don’t think we want to do that,” she thought to herself. Then, behind the crack dealer, she no- ticed “a gentleman Among the Missing continued from page 9 continued on page 12 “People said, ‘Well, how the hell are we supposed to help you if you don’t even know who you’re looking for?’” Lindsey Paison works for free for families looking for loved ones on the streets. BENNITO L. KELT Y