Party On! continued from page 7 1971. That’s when David Nolan, his wife and three of their friends were watching the news and heard that Richard Nixon planned to intervene in the economy in ways that they saw as overstepping. They decided to start their own political party, gathering others who felt the same way and holding a press conference announcing the formation of the Libertarian Party in January 1972. That year, the fi rst Libertarian National Convention was held in Denver. The party took off fast. By 1980, it was on the presidential ballot in all fi fty states. Today it’s the third biggest political party in the United States, with 2.4 million voters regis- tered nationally as of October 2021. Colorado had 42,000 registered Libertarians as of 2020. The party stands for individualism and opposes any form of government interven- tion; as a result, it shares beliefs with both the Democratic and Republican parties. For example, Libertarians have long supported gay marriage, decreasing the prison popula- tion and ending foreign intervention in wars, all positions that align closely with liberal ideals. But the party also supports limited federal government, abolishing taxation, and unregulated economic activity, items that align closely with conservative ideals. To gain traction, at times the party has leaned toward a more pragmatic approach to national politics, emphasizing parts of the platform that are more agreeable to the masses — particularly Republican masses — such as less taxation and smaller government rather than the ideological purity of no taxes at all. Mary-Kate Lizotte, a professor of political science in the Department of Social Sci- ences at Augusta University in Georgia, co- authored a 2021 paper titled “Understanding the appeal of libertarianism: Gender and race differences in the endorsement of lib- ertarian principles”; she says she suspects that the pragmatist wing of the Libertarian Party leans Republican because it prioritizes individualism and lack of government inter- ference over its other values. “Democrats also often largely endorse that idea of a meritocracy and self-reliance as well; they just happen to prioritize egali- tarianism over that individualism, and I think with Libertarians, it’s just the opposite,” Lizotte says. “They’re more in line with the Republican Party, which also tends to prioritize individualism.” The party member who gained the most recognition from that pragmatist approach was presidential nominee Gary Johnson, who won 4 percent of the popular vote in the 2016 election. On the other side of the spectrum was Ron Paul, the party’s 1988 nominee, who advocated for ideological purity rather than chasing mass appeal. In the book Beyond Donkeys and Ele- 8 phants: Minor Political Parties in Contempo- rary American Politics, Christopher Devine, an associate professor of political science at the University of Dayton, says that the question of whether the Libertarian Party should be “purely a vehicle for libertarian, lowercase L, ideology or if it should be a kind of libertarian-fl avored party that can actu- ally win elections” has haunted it for years. Devine’s research found that, in general, those who voted Libertarian weren’t as radical as the party’s platform. But looking back on it now, he says that his 2020 analysis almost feels like an obituary because of the ways that the party has changed since then. “Maybe this is just a brief detour and then they come back to where they were,” Devine adds, “but to the extent that this is a lasting change, it seems like a major shift in the party and a real break from the fi rst fi fty years.” At the heart of the change is the Mises Caucus. Named after the Mises Institute, a Libertarian think tank in Alabama that fol- lows the Austrian economics principles of its namesake, Ludwig von Mises, the Libertar- ian Mises Caucus was founded by Michael Heise in 2017. Its political action committee has raised $356,000 in 2022 alone, according to the nonprofi t OpenSecrets. and explain why Angela McArdle, the new national party chair, decided to run in 2020. The Libertarian Party had failed to take a stand on lockdowns, she says, missing a chance to let people know about the option of this third party. “What I would like to do at the national level if we ever get locked down again — and hopefully that does not happen — is to say that we oppose it and that we believe that your ability to go outside, engage in commerce, and interact with your friends and family is one of your foundational liberties,” McArdle explains. Harlos was also concerned when the national party failed to come out strong against lockdowns. She calls Johnson’s style of libertarian- ism “thick libertarianism” and Paul’s “thin libertarianism.” Thin Libertarians, she says, Jilletta Jarvis and then-Libertarian National Committee chair Joseph Bishop-Henchman. After Jeremy Kauffman, part of the New Hampshire party’s communications commit- tee, took control of the party’s Twitter account and began sharing provocative statements — including one about legalizing child labor and another about repealing the Civil Rights Act — Jarvis attempted to break away from the existing state party and form a new one. Bishop-Henchman supported her, but much of the national party leadership, including Harlos, did not, and Bishop-Henchman even- tually resigned in June 2021 over the issue. Harlos stood up for the existing New Hampshire party, and exposed Bishop- Henchman’s coordination with Jarvis on attempts to form a new party. But members of the national party leadership — who be- lieved that Bishop-Henchman had done the right thing, and that the Mises Caucus was infi ltrating the party to its detriment — still held a majority at that time. They voted to remove Harlos from her position. After that, similar movements to wrestle Mises Caucus power from local chapters in Delaware and Massachusetts emerged. Believing that those attempts were embold- ened by her removal, Harlos tried to help the local caucuses, offering free services as a registered parliamentarian. And she joined the Mises Caucus herself. “A lot of the Mises people, they’re younger Caryn Ann Harlos at the 2022 Libertarian National Convention. Some caucus members consider them- selves part of a radical arm, swooping in to save a party that doesn’t know what it is anymore. But while Libertarian Party membership seems to be leaning more intensely toward ideological purity, Devine points out that Ron Paul remains the father of the movement. “What it reminds us, really, is that the Lib- ertarian Party has not been one thing through- out fi fty-plus years,” Devine says. “There’s believe that an individual’s personal opinions on social issues are irrelevant to their libertari- anism as long as they don’t try to implement a law based on them. Thick Libertarians, on the other hand, believe in what thin Libertarians believe — but also demand that people be on a certain side of social issues. Harlos saw masks as one of those issues. Although she’s on the more liberal side of many social issues — she believes in gay mar- people,” Harlos says. “They’re guys, usu- ally, in their twenties; they don’t have a ton of money. Then older people, with more experience and more money, start coming against them. What are they going to do if somebody doesn’t step up to volunteer to help them? They’re pretty much helpless.” She appreciates their focus on local Lib- ertarian candidates and ballot measures, as well as creating new, county-level affi liates of the Libertarian Party. In Colorado, the Mises Caucus supported the 2019 Decriminalize Denver initiative that aimed to decriminalize psychedelic mushrooms. Other single-issue campaigns supported “Last I checked, Nazis didn’t like pink-haired white women who purposely chose not to reproduce and have lots of little white children.” always been some fl uctuation between the relative strength of different movements within the party. I’m not saying this is just the same thing all over again; I think it is a shift, but to anyone who thinks that this is just an alien force taking over the party, I would say there are some deeper roots.” The pandemic and resulting lockdowns and mask mandates may have helped shift the party toward a more radical viewpoint. Such policies go against the libertarian notion of individual choice and hands-off government, riage, abortion rights and the legalization of sex work — she doesn’t think that they have a place in the Libertarian platform. New Hampshire is a Libertarian hotbed, thanks to the Free State Project, founded in 2001, which recruited over 20,000 people to move to the state to start a liberty-minded community. The Mises Caucus became prominent in the state party. It was too prominent for some, including then-New Hampshire Libertarian Party chair by the Mises Caucus include creating co- alitions for gun rights, legalizing gold and silver as legal tender, and pushing for further federal legislation of hemp. Although Harlos felt secure in her choice to stand up for liberty, her removal from national offi ce came at a diffi cult time. She’d just resigned her job as a paralegal, and it was tough to fi nd a new one, because every potential employer would fi nd the Wikipedia page that noted she’d been removed from her position within the party. “People play these petty political games and don’t realize it follows people for the rest of their life when you do things like that,” she says. Even after her ousting, Harlos stayed active in the party, documenting Libertarian history from records kept in a storage locker near her Castle Rock home. And she continued contrib- uting to LPedia, the party’s collaborative web- site, cataloguing its history and happenings. History turned around quickly. The Mises Caucus nearly swept the party elections this year. When Harlos went to the national con- vention, she was given back her position as secretary, and the party amended the offi cial record to void her removal, noting that she hadn’t been given due process. According to Har- continued on page 10 JULY 14-20, 2022 WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | westword.com COURTESY OF CARYN ANN HARLOS