Party On! continued from page 8 los, only two of the newly elected national committee delegates aren’t members of the Mises Caucus or endorsed by it. With the Mises Caucus fi rmly in power, the party now plans to move forward with a new vision, leaving behind “wokeness.” But fi rst, the people leading the Libertarian Party are going to have to deal with charges of bigotry. For a time, Harlos says, the party had focused too much on forcing everyone to conform to the same set of social views rather than on opposing the coercive power of the state. “Some of the people who had more of the progressive views started…calling everyone who disagreed with them a Nazi and a bigot, which seems to be the stock- in-trade of today’s political discourse,” she notes. “The problem is, you say it enough times, you start to believe it, and when you think you’re fi ghting, like, literal Nazis, you will do almost anything.” As a result, the Mises Caucus now advo- cates for leaving social issues out of the party platform and focusing purely on libertarian ideology. Harlos praises the party for being the fi rst in America to “de-woke.” “It signals, kind of, a return to fundamen- tals and not what I call ‘hiding the ball,’” Harlos says. “The ultimate position of the Libertarian Party — it’s shocking to a lot of people, because we haven’t said it for years — when we say we want the state out of things, we literally mean that.” Under that view, the only roles for the state involve courts, police and a limited military. That means no public schools, no social welfare programs, no Americans With Disabilities Act and no declaring drugs ille- gal, among a slew of other positions. “The reality is there are always going to be people who reject us in the mainstream,” McArdle says. “That should never give us a reason to compromise our principles. It should never be something that infl uences the fundamental decisions that we make regarding how we message liberty.” According to Lizotte, third parties in the past have aligned themselves with a major party politically, as the Libertarian Party has done with the Republican Party. But mov- ing away from that could be a logical next step, since that Republican Party alignment doesn’t seem to be winning the Libertarian Party many victories. “If, at this point, they feel like that’s not get- ting them the end results that they’re looking for and that they’re just sort of being taken advantage of by the Republican Party and taken for granted, then I think it makes a lot of sense that they would sort of re-evaluate what they should be moving forward,” Lizotte says. In her research, Lizotte found that people who support libertarian principles tend to deride the Democratic Party. But McArdle doesn’t buy Lizotte’s theory. She thinks the Libertarian Party has done too much lately to placate liberals rather than conservatives. “We want to distinguish ourselves, obvi- 10 ously, from the other two parties, but not to be so nasty and combative to people who are social conservatives,” she says. “The party, historically, at least in the last twenty years, has done a lot to reach out to people on the left, but they have really kind of ignored, and maybe even ridiculed, people on the right. So what we’re trying to do is to outreach to people on both sides of the political spectrum without compromising our principles.” During the 2021 Pride Month, she points out, the national party sent an email about “pansexuality.” While the Libertarian Party has always defended gay marriage, McArdle says that pansexuality is a left-leaning buzz- word that wasn’t needed to send the message that the party supports LGBTQ+ rights. A political party’s platform can’t require its members to be a good person, Harlos says: “That’s nothing to do with a party. There are assholes in every party.” To that end, at the 2022 convention in Reno, the party changed its platform. The but to say we defend the rights of all people? Now, that actually says something.” The statement now indicates action rather than feelings, she points out. It doesn’t insist that anyone in the party has an obliga- tion to condemn bigotry, or take action to defend someone else’s rights. “I don’t think that equity keeps out big- otry,” McArdle says. “In order to make things quote-unquote equitable, you usually have to cut someone else down and remove them from their status. Oftentimes, that means you’re removing or cutting down someone who has worked very hard and achieved a position on their own merits.” Although McArdle says the Mises Caucus actually has a more diverse makeup than the party at large, Devine says it tends to avoid specifi cally addressing its stance on bigotry. that they’re a victim, taking attention away from those who are actually oppressed. The Libertarian Party simply doesn’t see a role for the government in preventing oppression, she notes. That’s why a popular saying in the party is this: “Some of the most terrifying words in the world are ‘I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.’” If the government does need to step in, McArdle notes, it should be on a local rather than a federal level. Usually, though, it should be up to the individual and the community to fi ght back. “We believe that individuals have the right to bear arms, that you can fi ght back against someone, and we don’t believe in Utopia,” she says. “We understand the fal- lible nature of human beings, and I believe that it’s reasonable to call upon friends and family and people around you for help.” Now that the Libertarian Party has “de- woked” itself in order to focus on pure libertarianism instead of reaching out to dis- affected Democrats and Republicans, Harlos thinks that its membership will increase. “If you had a hamburger joint, maybe Libertarian Party of Delaware’s Amy LePore (top) and national party chair Angela McArdle both supported Caryn Ann Harlos’s reelection. “They would not identify, I think, as supporting bigotry or prejudice of any kind, but they also don’t want to talk about it much,” Devine says, noting that the line condemning big- otry has been in and out of the party platform over the years. “Mises Caucus folks will say, well, there’s no shift going on here. We’re just taking away line that used to condemn bigotry as ir- rational and repugnant was replaced with this: “We reject the idea that a natural right can ever impose an obligation upon others to fulfi ll that ‘right.’ We uphold and defend the rights of every person, regardless of their race, ethnicity, or any other aspect of their identity. … Members of private organizations retain their rights to set whatever standards of association they deem appropriate, and in- dividuals are free to respond with ostracism, boycotts, and other free market solutions.” “It basically says the same thing, but with less ambiguity — but for some reason, people lost their frickin’ minds,” Harlos says. “‘We condemn bigotry as irrational and repugnant’ — that’s not a political statement; that’s a virtue signal. What policy does that translate into in libertarianism? Nothing, some of the performative ‘wokeism,’ as they describe it, of the party in recent years, get- ting back to basics,” Devine continues. “A lot of other people say, ‘Come on, we can read between the lines.’ Not talking about certain things and then trying to provoke people on other points, this is a cultural shift, and one that has bigotry at its root.” But Harlos points to herself as an example of how the Mises Caucus isn’t bigoted, much less leaning into Nazi-like ideas. “Last I checked, Nazis didn’t like pink- haired white women who purposely chose not to reproduce and have lots of little white children,” she says. “Everyone’s realized that the cancel mob is great until it comes for you — and it always comes for you.” Harlos believes that “wokeness” has caused people to always search for a reason before trying to convince people who like hot dogs better that hamburgers are great, you reach for the people who already like hamburgers,” she suggests. However, Devine questions how the Mises Caucus will measure success if not by winning more voters in national elections. “Who did Gary Johnson really inspire to become a lasting, committed, ideologically pure member of the party?” Devine asks. “According to the Mises Caucus? Not many. And there’s probably some truth to that, maybe some exaggeration. So for the Mises Caucus, how do they know that they’ve done a better job than anyone else?” Devine suspects they will focus on local numbers in states and counties, as well as how many libertarian-minded ballot mea- sures pass across the country. He thinks the question of how strong and lasting a shift this is for the Libertarian Party might not be answered until 2024, when the party nominates a candidate for president. Will it be a Mises Caucus rabble-rouser like comedian Dave Smith, who headlined the 2022 convention of the Libertarian Party of Colorado? Or will it be someone like for- mer Republican congressman Justin Amash, who might be a bridge between the party’s pragmatist past and radical future? Either way, Harlos is excited. In the em- bodiment of the local focus touted by the Mises Caucus, she’s running for Castle Rock Town Council this November. The race is nonpartisan, but Harlos is making it clear that she wants to push the town closer to libertarian principles, with less government involvement in people’s lives. “With actual, simple, clear, not-obfuscat- ing-the-issue-of-what-we-believe messaging, I think that we could make a huge impact — and for third parties, an impact isn’t always winning elections,” Harlos says. “I don’t care if I’m in a room talking to fi ve people or 500 people. You never know: The one person you’re talking to could be the person that’s go- ing to change the world. Every person you talk to is important. It’s not only about numbers.” Email the author at catie.cheshire@westword. com. JULY 14-20, 2022 WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | westword.com ANGELA MCARDLE COURTESY OF CARYN ANN HARLOS