4 APRIL 25-MAY 1, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | Put to the Test COLORADO DAS FRUSTRATED WITH CBI OVER LACK OF TRANSPARENCY SURROUNDING DISGRACED DNA ANALYST MISSY WOODS. BY C HRIS PEREZ For district attorneys across the state — both past and present — Yvonne “Missy” Woods is a name that keeps many of them up at night. “The impact of her misconduct cannot be overstated,” says 17th Judicial District Attorney Brian Mason of Woods, a disgraced DNA expert who used to work for the Colo- rado Bureau of Investigation and was outed last year for manipulating data. “I have had former employees of the DA’s offi ce, former prosecutors, reach out saying, ‘Was that terrible murder case I was on im- pacted by this?’” Mason tells Westword. “They built relationships with families and victims’ families and thought that they had secured justice in these cases and that these cases were done, and that the victims and their families could have peace. And that is thrown into question now by these revelations from CBI.” CBI announced last month that Woods — who retired in November 2023, shortly before the agency began its investigation — was found to have “deviated from standard testing protocols and cut corners, calling into question the reliability of the testing she con- ducted” throughout her decades-long career. She deleted and altered data that “concealed her tampering with controls,” deleted data that “concealed her failure to troubleshoot issues within the testing process” and failed to provide “thorough documentation in the case record” related to tests she performed, the agency says. Left in Woods’s wake are hundreds of cases with “anomalies” and evidence of data ma- nipulation — 652, to be exact — and countless more where she was endorsed as an expert or witness. CBI is currently conducting a review of Woods’s work from 1994 to 2008 after identifying anomalies between 2008 and 2023. CBI says it has “regularly engaged the district attorneys from around the state and provided them with critical information about the investigation and its impact on cases in their jurisdictions.” But Mason and other DAs tell Westword that CBI offi cials haven’t been as forthright with information as they claim. “It’s been some fi ve months since this fi rst came out, and we’re still getting information in dribs and drabs,” says 18th Judicial District Attorney John Kellner. “Prosecutors around the state have waited anxiously for information because of the im- pact on victims, the accused, and our ability to do justice,” adds Boulder County District Attorney Michael Dougherty. “There are a lot of questions that remain to be answered.” “I think we are all frustrated by the scandal itself and the attacks on our cases, but also on what we perceive to be a lack of transparency from CBI on exactly what the conduct was and exactly what the impact on our cases will be,” Mason explains. “And that’s deeply discourag- ing for me, personally, and also for my offi ce as we communicate with victims and with people in the community who are impacted by this.” Dougherty’s offi ce currently has fi fteen open cases and 55 closed cases with Woods as an endorsed witness. “We have one fi led petition for post-conviction relief based on this issue that is pending, and another one that was previously pending and is now on hold,” he says. One case that has grabbed headlines is the 2019 conviction of Garrett Coughlin, who al- legedly murdered three people in Coal Creek Canyon back in 2017. Woods had performed forensic analysis on evidence samples. In 2020, Coughlin successfully fi led an appeal for a new trial and got his convic- tion tossed out after jurors were accused of lying on their questionnaires. Last month, he was granted a continuance after the CBI investigation of Woods’s misconduct was brought up by his defense lawyers. “Coughlin, who is completely in the dark about what actually happened and what CBI is doing about it, asks the Court to order the prosecution to immediately provide the fol- lowing information to the defense,” his law- yers said in a February 5 motion for discovery. “In what manner Ms. Woods: Altered data for evidence items, Altered data and/or extract of Quality Control samples, Analyzed data multiple times without retaining all data sets.” Coughlin’s attorneys are seeking fi fteen specifi c discovery items. “The People con- tacted CBI and sent them a copy of the defense motion to get discovery,” Dough- erty wrote in a February 29 fi ling. “At CBI’s request, a formal discovery request was submitted to that agency on February 12, 2024. The language used in that discovery request was language suggested by CBI as a way of obtaining the materials at issue.” However, when it came time to actually discuss the “anomalies” in question, CBI chose to stay relatively mum. “On February 21, 2024, the People re- ceived materials from CBI,” Dougherty said in the February 29 fi ling. “The materials included the entire litigation packet from the original rounds of testing. However, on this issue of the anomalies, it included very limited information.” On February 28, the Colorado Attorney General’s Offi ce provided additional materi- als in response to two of Coughlin’s requests. But the court issued a protective order limit- ing their dissemination. In fi lings, Dougherty’s offi ce has said it agrees that Coughlin is entitled to the information that his defense attorneys are requesting. Both parties claim that CBI has been dragging its feet, but the bureau insists it’s being as forthcoming as possible. “CBI exchanged information regarding impacted cases with all 22 district attorneys as those impacts were discovered, through regu- lar updates,” says strategic communications director Rob Low. “CBI also issued credibility disclosures regarding its fi ndings about Ms. Woods’s conduct as required by law. CBI has provided the fi ndings of the internal affairs in- vestigation in response to multiple subpoenas issued by district attorneys’ offi ces around the state. CBI continues to provide information about all of its cases to its law enforcement partners through the discovery process.” According to Low, CBI has provided “the fi ndings” of its 94-page internal affairs report on Woods in response to multiple subpoenas issued by DA’s offi ces around the state. But beyond that, exactly what type of informa- tion the agency is providing is unclear. “They’ve talked about releasing investiga- tions in response to subpoenas. That right there tells you that many DA’s offi ces have had to subpoena this information because we weren’t getting it otherwise,” Mason says. Dougherty’s offi ce had to fi ght for the 94-page report. “The prosecutor’s mission is to do justice,” he says. “So anytime an issue arises involving the integrity of the evidence or the credibility of a witness, we take it very seriously.” Kellner’s offi ce — which oversees Arapa- hoe, Douglas, Elbert and Lincoln counties — is currently looking at over 400 cases in which Woods was endorsed as an expert or witness. “We have over sixty cases that CBI has identifi ed that there may be issues with her work,” he tells Westword. “[CBI] said it them- selves: It calls into question the accuracy not just of her work, but frankly, the lab’s work. And so we’re going to be dealing with that, I think, for years to come. There’s going to be a lot of litigation. And obviously, we want to defend the righteous convictions. We want to make sure, though, also, that people were con- victed fairly and with competent evidence.” Mason estimates that the 17th Judicial District has over 200 cases in which Woods was somehow involved. “Now, whether or not the allegations in what she has or hasn’t done impact all of those cases in our jurisdiction, we just don’t know yet,” he says. “I’m just re- ally worried about what kind of impact this is going to have on closed cases. Cases that had been tried ten, twenty years ago. Missy Woods was one of their analysts for several decades, and she worked on a lot of cases. And I’m very concerned about what sort of impact this will have on some of our very old, closed cases. You know, these are cases where witnesses haven’t been spoken to in years — sometimes decades — and may not be reachable, may not be alive. To get in touch with people and bring back police offi cers or detectives who would have worked on those cases, who would have conducted initial interviews — all of that is a Herculean effort that may or may not even be possible or feasible in some of these old cases. We just don’t know.” According to Low, CBI “understands the frustration” coming from Colorado DAs and says the agency “shares in that frustration” as it conducts a comprehensive investigation and review of Woods’s work. In the meantime, CBI Director Chris Schaefer tells Westword that staffers remain committed to maintaining high-quality labo- ratory work and accurate results. “No stone will remain unturned as we address Woods’s misconduct,” he says. “Ad- ditionally, I have complete confi dence in the integrity of our Forensic Services employees and the accuracy of the reports they issue.” Email the author at [email protected]. NEWS KEEP UP ON DENVER NEWS AT WESTWORD.COM/NEWS GETTY IMAGES