8 MARCH 21-27, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | plete with a stripper pole and ATM in the basement — and Manigo admitted that he did not live there. As part of a settlement agreement with the city, Manigo voluntarily surrendered his short-term rental license for 5516 Sable Street in December 2020 but was allowed to reapply for a new license beginning in July 2021. He secured a short-term rental license for 12240 East 50th Avenue fi ve months later. “The review of the application at the 12240 East 50th Avenue address did not fi nd suffi cient grounds to deny the application,” Escudero says. While investigating the violent crimes committed at 12240 East 50th Avenue, the city discovered that this house was not Manigo’s primary residence, either, since he rented it out so frequently. In addition, inves- tigators found that Manigo falsely claimed to earn no income from the rental on his renewal application for the rental license, despite the city estimating that he earned at least $80,000 from the house in one year. Manigo’s short-term rental license for 12240 East 50th Avenue was revoked on October 30. He did not appear at the required hearing regarding his discipline. He will be eligible to apply for another license in October 2025. The State of Airbnbs in Denver To date, Denver has revoked just fi ve short- term rental licenses since the city began regulating them in 2017. Nine other licenses have been surrendered, some voluntarily and some compelled by the city. Manigo is the only owner to ever lose a license more than once, and the fi rst person to lose a license since 2020. Of the fourteen licenses revoked or sur- rendered, ten were due to the rental property not being the owner’s primary residence. The other four — including Manigo’s two license losses — were because of violent parties disturbing the neighborhood. One Airbnb Halloween party resulted in multiple fi ghts, alleged assaults and one man fi ring a gun into the street outside 624 East 12th Avenue in Denver’s Capitol Hill neighborhood on November 1, 2019. While investigating the incident, city of- fi cials discovered that the short-term rental license holder, Shannon Baker, lived in Cali- fornia and was not using the Denver house as her primary residence. She applied for a California driver’s license just one month after receiving the short-term rental license, according to city reports. Baker surrendered her rental license in January 2020 and was prohibited from reapplying for one year. A week later, on November 9, 2019, police were called to an Airbnb at 1008 South Madi- son Street fi ve times for noise complaints, disturbances and gunshots. A party inside of the Belcaro rental had grown out of control, culminating in attendees fi ring guns outside of the house in unknown directions before driving off. No one was injured. The house’s owner, Madeline Philley, had received her short-term rental license only two months prior, according to city reports. She surrendered her license in January 2020 and was also barred from applying for a new license for one year. Neither Baker nor Philley were ever granted new licenses, according to city records. The city’s Airbnb issues don’t stop at vio- lence. A Denver man, Shaunik Raheja, was indicted on federal fraud charges in January for allegedly running a national scam using Airbnb and Vrbo to defraud thousands of victims by posting fake or duplicate listings for rental properties. The scheme generated more than $8.5 million in 2018 and 2019, according to the indictment. Raheja used two people who claimed to be his long-term tenants to secure short-term rental licenses for two Denver properties in 2019, according to Excise & Licenses. He also held his own short-term rental license for 3315 Navajo Street from 2019 to 2020. He applied for a license at 3442 Osage Street in 2021, but withdrew the application after the city asked Raheja to sign an affi davit attesting that the home was his primary residence. Only 175 complaints were fi led against Denver short-term rentals in 2023 — the lowest since the city started regulating them in 2017, according to Excise & Licenses. By comparison, there were an average of 278 complaints each year from 2018 to 2022, peaking at 479 complaints in 2019. But com- plaints could be going to the wrong place. Police were notifi ed about the violent and disruptive incidents occurring at Manigo’s 50th Avenue house beginning in April 2021, while Excise & Licenses apparently didn’t begin its investigation into the rental until May 2023. “When the Department of Excise & Li- censes receives complaints, every complaint is investigated,” Escudero says. “When the city uncovers information about rules and regulations being violated, the city takes enforcement action, as was the case at both [of Manigo’s] addresses.” Denver residents can submit complaints regarding short-term rentals by calling 311. Neighbors can report when rentals disturb the neighborhood, host suspicious activity, operate without a license and more; in some circumstances, the city will provide a free mediation service to try to resolve the confl ict. When someone runs a short-term rental without a license, the city typically gives a written warning, followed by a $150 fi ne if the rental does not cease within thirty days. A $500 fi ne comes thirty days after that, then $999 after another thirty days. From there, the city can issue an additional $999 fi ne every day that the activity continues. The city also asks rental platforms to remove the listing or face fi nes for processing an illegal transaction. In extreme cases, the city can issue a crimi- nal citation, which could result in jail time, Escudero says: “If they won’t get a license or can’t because they are legally prohibited from hosting a short-term rental at an address, the city takes strong enforcement efforts.” There are currently 2,748 active short- term rental licenses in Denver, Escudero says, and the city estimates that 92 percent of all advertised short-term rentals in Denver have the required licensing. Since 2017, the city has denied 284 applications for new licenses and license renewals. “The city has seen consistent growth and more compliance over the last year,” Escudero says. “Denver has one of the most successfully regulated short-term rental markets in America in terms of licensing compliance. We are proud of the success we’ve had with a high compliance rate and consequences for illegal operators.” The Life Lost Before they learned about Manigo’s his- tory, Rigo’s family held a vigil outside of the Montbello Airbnb where he was killed. Dozens of Rigo’s friends and family members gathered in the driveway where he died to light candles and release balloons. Manigo Rental Breakdown continued from page 6 Bobby Manigo’s Tripadvisor profi le and the ad for his Denver rental house — still listed fi ve months after the city revoked his short-term rental license. TRIPADVISOR TRIPADVISOR