8 MARCH 7-13, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | Title Board hearing, Dumm and the cabal of election nerds will be represented by self- described “progressive law fi rm” Tierney Lawrence Stiles. (The same law fi rm was involved with the failed legal challenge to keep Donald Trump off Colorado’s presi- dential ballot.) They’re hoping to convince the board that Thiry’s measure would reform Colorado election law far beyond its stated aims and that it should not be approved as a single ballot measure. Dumm has actually worked directly with Thiry before, during a 2018 redistricting process. When I ask what he’s like in person, she says she never wanted to “crawl inside that brain.” A few days later, she emails me a follow- up response: “To steal a line from Humphrey Bogart, he’s just like every other man, but more so.” Kent Thiry’s Business of Blood Before Thiry took on Colorado politics, he ran a big business for people’s dying kidneys. DaVita and its competitor Fresenius make up the duopoly that controls dialysis, a treatment for severe kidney disease, throughout the United States. As our population ages, and as chronic kidney diseases become more prevalent, the global dialysis market is only forecasted to rise and rise. In order to boost its bottom line, DaVita has earned a reputation for providing medical care so shoddy that it regularly endangers patients’ lives. Kent Thiry announced he was moving DaVita from California to Colorado in 2009 after the company was promised more than $6 million in economic incentives both from the State of Colorado and the City of Denver. DaVita’s world headquarters — allegedly known as “Casa del Mundo” by its employees — now dominates Denver’s skyline. (When I asked a spokesperson for Gov- ernor Jared Polis what benefi ts the State of Colorado saw in return for the incentives given to DaVita, the response was only that “no state tax credits have been provided to DaVita since Governor Polis took offi ce.”) Since the relocation to Colorado, and all while under Thiry’s control, DaVita has strung together a long list of massive legal settlements. In 2014, via the Department of Justice: “DaVita paid $350m to resolve allegations… it gave illegal kickbacks to physicians who referred patients to DaVita” including “non- disparagement agreements that would have prevented the physicians from referring their patients to other dialysis providers.” In 2015, via the Department of Justice: DaVita “has agreed to pay $450 million [for] creating unnecessary waste in administering the drugs Zemplar and Venofer to dialysis patients, and then billing the federal govern- ment for such avoidable waste.” In 2018, via Reuters: “A federal jury in Colorado has awarded $383.5 million to the families of three patients who said they suffered cardiac arrests and died soon after receiving dialysis treatments at clinics run by DaVita Inc.” In How to Make a Killing: Blood, Death and Dollars in American Medicine, an exposé of DaVita and the larger dialysis industry, investigative reporter Tom Mueller writes that the settlements are an integral part of DaVita’s business model: “All manner of fl agrant misconduct, including serious criminal charges, is routinely resolved by the payment of a legal settlement, which often represents a fraction of the money that the fi rm made during the period of the alleged fraud.” In the same year as DaVita’s settlement in the wrongful-death lawsuit, a ballot mea- sure in California, Proposition 8, aimed to improve care for dialysis patients and conditions for dialysis workers by capping dialysis companies’ revenues at 115 percent of costs to deliver care, with earnings over that amount rebated back to patients. Prop 8 was promoted by SEIU, the union that represents health-care workers in Cali- fornia. In How to Make a Killing, Mueller writes that during the fi ght over Prop 8, Thiry internally “reviled labor unions as un-American” and “affi rmed his fi rm’s right to dictate all aspects of dialysis care.” Thiry and his allies spent $110 million to kill Prop 8, and in the process set a national record for spending on ballot measures. In 2021, Thiry himself was indicted by the Department of Justice on charges that he colluded with other health-care compa- nies not to solicit each others’ employees in order to quash the workers’ earnings and opportunities. In 2022, he was acquitted of all charges and duly continued his pattern of shrugging off his company’s legal troubles. A blandly handsome native Wisconsinite, Thiry cultivates a milquetoast outward per- sona. His Twitter bio partially reads “Love being a father of two.” When speaking to the press, Thiry sticks to mild Unite America- style talking points. He declined my repeated requests for an interview, instead sharing a statement: “Elections belong to voters — not political parties. I strongly support efforts to bring truly open primaries to Colorado because voters have a right to choose any candidate in any election and they have grown weary of insiders gaming the system.” That milquetoast persona is belied by Thiry’s personal idiosyncrasies. As the Den- ver Post reported in 2009, Thiry began rally- ing his workforce by utilizing the slogans and imagery of the classic 1844 Alexandre Dumas novel The Three Musketeers after watching the 1998 Leonardo DiCaprio musketeer movie, The Man in the Iron Mask. “I looked over, and tears were rolling down his face,” a co-worker and friend, Doug Vlchek, recalled to the Post. “That’s the guy who is passionate about what he is doing, whether it’s making a difference at work or watching a movie.” Thiry happily posed for press photos at the DaVita offi ce in front of a mural depicting big hats with feathers and swordsmen and other signifi ers of musketeer culture. He’s known for hosting parties at his large and lovely home in Cherry Hills. Once, mid-party, he promised a large donation to the charity of choice to whomever stayed cutting it up on the dance fl oor the longest. One party-goer told me he spotted a mannequin wearing a Three Musketeers outfi t on display in a room in the house. Another recalls Thiry standing up in front of a party crowd and reciting, from memory, the Gettysburg Address. In 2017, Last Week Tonight With John Oliver devoted an entire episode to break- ing down DaVita’s exploitative business practices and personal quirks — and utilized, to great effect, footage from internal DaVita conferences in which Thiry does barefoot tumble rolls to Bob Seger while dressed like an old-timey swordsman. When the John Oliver segment aired, Thiry was exploring a run for Colorado governor. Within months, he announced he would not enter the race. (While considering running, he switched his party affi liation to Republican from unaffi liated; after giving up the idea, he switched back.) The language he used alarmed many in the cabal of election nerds that, ever since, he’s just been waiting for a more opportune time to try again. He told reporters, “I have held on to the dream of running for offi ce since I was ten years old.” What Does Kent Thiry Really Want? I meet Wendy Howell, the state director for the Colorado chapter of the Working Families Party, in the conference room of a beguilingly brutalist offi ce building across from the State Capitol. A cheery and pug- nacious speaker, Howell represents the left fl ank of the cabal. “Given that our North Star is building governing power for the multiracial working class, we tend to look at any kind of shift in the rules around elections with a pretty hard eye,” Howell says. Howell points out that, in the era of MAGA Republicans, a “corporate Republi- can” like Thiry would have a very tough time making it through a Republican primary. Under an open primary system, though, he would have a much better chance of outspending the competition and forcing his way forward. Echoing a sentiment I’d hear again and again, Howell suggests that Thiry is ultimately shifting the landscape to favor his own political aspirations: “This is a billionaire who is trying to game the system so he can run for governor in 2026.” Howell takes a well-timed comedic pause, then locks back into her fl ow: “And I’m sorry, but Kent Thiry is a ridiculous human being. This is a man who literally rode into his employee meetings on a horse in a Three Musketeers costume. If he were anyone but a billionaire, he would be the weirdest neighbor you have. continued on page 10 Kent Thiry continued from page 6 “THE LARGEST AND FASTEST-GROWING SEGMENT IN THE ELECTORATE ARE PEOPLE WHO DON’T BELONG TO EITHER POLITICAL PARTY.” Unite America head Nick Troiano’s new book, The Primary Solution, was published in February; Shad Murib is chair of the Colorado Democratic Party. SIMON AND SCHUSTER/HANNAH METZGER COURTESY OF SHAD MURIB