6 MARCH 7-13, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | DaVita, the Denver-based dialysis giant that has paid out nearly $1 billion in settlements since 2012 in lawsuits alleging everything from Medicare fraud to wrongful deaths. Thiry and Unite America’s current press- ing concern is their joint home base, Colo- rado, where they are pushing a constitutional measure for the November ballot that would bring open primaries and ranked-choice voting to elections statewide beginning in 2026, from the state legislature and governor to the U.S. Senate. Thiry is part of a network of tycoons push- ing open primaries and ranked-choice voting nationally. Collectively, they’ve spent mil- lions boosting Unite America and pushing lookalike ballot measures in Massachusetts, Oregon, New York, Maine, Alaska, Nevada and, now, Colorado. Thiry says his goal is to take this billionaire-backed election reform push and turn it into “a true movement” like “civil rights, like gay marriage, like #MeToo.” States have wide leeway to run their elections however they want. For a group like Unite America and its wealthy backers, then, spending millions to push election reform ballot measures state by state is a gradual but enormously impactful way to tilt the axis of the country’s political system. If Thiry gets his way in Colorado, his strategy could well become a blueprint for wealthy power brokers nationwide. Ellen Dumm is a Colorado communica- tions consultant who specializes in election reform. She’s also part of a local crew that has sprung up to resist Thiry’s measure. A “cabal of election nerds,” Dumm jokes. The group is gravely alarmed by the potential impacts of Thiry’s reforms — above all, the possibil- ity that Thiry is setting the stage to make it easier to run for governor himself in 2026. On March 6, Colorado’s Title Board, a non-partisan three-person panel with ju- risdiction over ballot measures, will hold a hearing to evaluate Thiry’s proposed reform. The cabal and its lawyers will be there, hop- ing to stop the measure before it ever makes it to the ballot “The changes, taken together, would make it easier for powerful, wealthy people to control elections,” Dumm says. “And Unite America, obviously, has boatloads and boat- loads of money.” The Alaska-fi cation of America Born and raised in Milford, Pennsylvania, Troiano says he’s always had an “affi nity towards civic engagement,” to “leaving a community better than how you found it.” Smiling, he adds, “I joined student council in second grade, and it’s been a snowball rolling downhill ever since.” In 2014, then fresh out of Georgetown, he switched his affi liation from Republican to In- dependent to run for a Pennsylvania House of Representatives seat, managing an admirable 13 percent of the vote at 24 years old. Soon after, he joined the Centrist Project, a group founded by Dartmouth professor Charlie Wheelan that originally focused on helping elect self-described “moderate” candidates. In 2018, the Centrist Project rebranded as Unite America and then began shifting to a more ambitious goal: reforming electoral systems nationwide. As Unite America’s executive director, Troiano says, “I have the fortune of being in a position to do something good for the country as a whole. That’s not just an op- portunity, but a responsibility.” In February, Troiano published a book, The Primary Solution, that promises to save “our democracy from the fringes.” It features promotional blurbs from Mi- chael Bloomberg, Andrew Yang and Arnold Schwarzenegger (“This book offers thought- provoking ideas to terminate polarization and extremism in America”). In the book, Troiano writes that “abolishing partisan primaries” is “the single most important thing we can do” to hold the government “accountable to delivering better results.” Troiano generally avoids specifying what those actual desired results are. He shares that he’s worried about the national debt and that his parents voted for Obama in 2008 and Trump in 2016. Mostly, though, his sales pitch is full of vague paeans to unity and reconciliation. It is well-honed, emotional and undeniably effective. “The largest and fastest-growing seg- ment in the electorate are people who don’t belong to either political party,” he says. “You wouldn’t necessarily know that by the constant maps of red and blue — but this is a country of purple.” Troiano cites proprietary Unite America research that shows that a disproportionate number of independents who don’t partici- pate in partisan primaries are young people and military veterans. “It’s stunning that we’re telling the people who fought for our country and who are the future of our country, ‘You don’t get to have a voice in who our leaders are,’” he says. “It’s wrong, on its face.” In 2020, Alaska adopted open primaries and ranked-choice voting. In the fi rst cycle of elections after the reforms, former Repub- lican vice-presidential nominee Sarah Palin lost a race for a House seat to a Democrat, and Republican Lisa Murkowski defeated a more right-wing challenger to hold on to her Senate seat. In the wake of those results, the system was widely praised for boosting moderates just as its backers had promised. (Some pundits also pointed out that those results were most likely under a traditional electoral system, too.) In November 2024, Troiano points out, “half a dozen states might take” Alaska-style initiatives “to the ballot to reform prima- ries.” In Arizona, Montana, South Dakota and Idaho, measures are moving forward through the process of getting on the bal- lot. In Nevada, an Alaska-style measure is already on the ballot. The Nevada measure’s backers have spent more than $20 million pushing it forward. Those backers include Kent Thiry’s Unite America co-chair, Kathryn Murdoch, Rupert Murdoch’s daughter-in-law; hedge-fund billionaire and GOP mega-donor Kenneth Griffi n; Katherine Gehl, a scion of food man- ufacturing giant Gehl Foods; and Action Now, a group founded by another activist hedge-fund billionaire, John Arnold. Gehl, Murdoch and Arnold’s Action Now also donate directly to Unite America. Unite America spent over $3 million backing Alaska’s reform, the original impetus for this current swell of reforms. Within a de- cade, Unite America hopes to get a majority of the states to follow Alaska. Troiano says that will “enfranchise or empower millions of more voters” and will “liberate dozens of U.S. representatives and senators to govern to do what we hire them to do — work with each other to solve the major problems that the voters care about.” “The 800-Pound Gorilla of the Ballot Process” Ellen Dumm’s “cabal of election nerds” rep- resents a spectrum of political voices — from mainstream Democrats to activist lawyers — that collectively believe Alaska-style reforms in Colorado will have one impact that Unite America doesn’t ever mention: Wealthy candidates will gain massive advantages. If all of Thiry’s proposed reforms are ap- proved, the only way candidates in Colorado could get on ballots would be by collecting signatures. While that sounds democratic, in practice it means paying signature collectors to go out into the fi eld and solicit signatures directly from residents throughout the state, and that’s hugely expensive. Getting as few as 8,000 signatures can cost as much as $120,000. Many of Dumm’s allies in the cabal fi rst met while pushing a suite of reforms in 2013 aimed at making voting in Colorado as ac- cessible as possible. A little over a decade later, they reconnected to push back against Thiry. The group jokes that it’s kind of like getting the band back together. Shad Murib is one of Dumm’s allies in the push against Thiry’s ballot measure. He was born and raised outside of Denver to parents who emigrated from Lebanon; he and his wife, former state lawmaker Kerry Dono- van, own a ranch where they raise Scottish Highland cattle for beef. He’s also the head of Colorado’s Democratic Party. Speaking about Colorado’s current elec- tion systems, he swells with pride. “Every hurdle you could put in front of somebody to make it harder for them to vote — we’ve removed those,” Murib says. Of the system that Thiry is proposing, he says, “well-funded special interests are gonna love this system. Political consultants are gonna love this system. People are gonna make a lot of money off of the gamifi cation of our elections. The grifters in this business are so excited by this.” Murib’s fears of “gamifi cation” are bol- stered by the recent history of manipulation of ranked-choice voting and open primaries — also known, due to their chaotic nature, as jungle primaries — in California. In the current race for a Senate seat, Representa- tive Adam Schiff (D-California) is spending money to boost the name recognition of a weak Republican opponent in hopes that the underdog beats out Schiff’s closest in-party competitor and provides Schiff an easier road to victory. As University of California San Diego professor Thad Kousser has writ- ten: “Welcome to the jungle primary, where races can become more about strategic fi ghts and less about battles of ideas.” The Colorado Title Board evaluates whether a proposed ballot measure is lim- ited to a “single subject,” meaning its focus is limited to a single reform. To navigate the Title Board’s careful vetting, Kent Thiry has hired a gaggle of attorneys from a massive corporate law fi rm, Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, who are currently pushing application after application through the Title Board. Scott Wasserman is the president of the Bell Policy Center, which focuses on eco- nomic mobility issues in Colorado, and a longtime critic of Thiry’s political actions. “You can fl ood the ballot process and eventually get your title,” Wasserman says, “if you have $5 million and a dream.” Along with Brownstein, Thiry is using a consulting fi rm, the 76 Group, which is run by Josh Penry, a former Republican member of the Colorado Senate, to help him push through his measure. Penry is widely seen as Thiry’s well-compensated right-hand man in his quest to reform Colorado politics. In 2020, Penry bragged to KFF Health News that Thiry is “the 800-pound gorilla of the ballot initiative process in Colorado.” The former CEO, Penry added, “wields more power in an informal way than virtually all the elected offi cials.” Getting through the Title Board is a mun- dane and technical process with huge ramifi ca- tions: Once measures pass the Title Board, a wealthy backer like Thiry can spend millions to pay collectors to amass the 124,000 signatures needed to get on the ballot. Once the measure is on the ballot, Thiry can again spend freely, running ads that promote the measure to the voters in order to get over the 55 percent threshold to pass the measure into law. At the March 6 continued on page 8 Kent Thiry continued from page 5 KENTTHIRY.COM Kent Thiry is reshaping Colorado’s election landscape.