Think Again continued from page 9 orado Legislature, Strohm says. “The legisla- tive council will give that a fi scal note that really just says the tax increase will raise this much more revenue. That doesn’t take into account dynamic impact — like how there will be less money in disposable income in an individual’s pocket. “This really is a tool for the public,” she adds. “We want this to help inform and educate the public.” The group describes itself as non-partisan, but CSI is not exactly ideologically neutral. Strohm has a background in conserva- tive politics. She served as president of the Starboard Group, a political fundraising and consulting fi rm that has a history of work- ing with Republican candidates and causes. She’s married to Josh Penry, a Republican who served as the minority leader in the Colorado Senate and is now a political con- sultant himself. CSI is non-partisan “in name only,” says Ian Silverii, a Democratic operative and Den- ver Post columnist who’s married to Demo- cratic lawmaker Brittany Pettersen, now a candidate in Colorado’s 7th Congressional District. “And they have to do that to maintain their 501(c)(3) tax status. ... They should not be allowed to walk around pretending like they don’t have preferred electoral outcomes in mind, which is to elect more Republicans.” CSI “exists to promote a conservative agenda and, indirectly, Republican candi- dates,” says Ari Armstrong, a libertarian thought leader in Colorado. “Not that there’s anything wrong with that. That’s pretty standard in the policy world.” But Strohm pushes back on the assertion that CSI tilts Republican or conservative. “I think the facts are the facts. Look at our team members. Look at our board. It’s not true. We haven’t really felt the need to respond to it,” Strohm says. “Our team in- cludes Rs and Ds and Us. We believe at the core that we cannot drive forward toward attainable proactive solutions unless we all come together.” But a look at the board and team shows that CSI defi nitely skews Republican. While CSI has brought on a bipartisan 10 range of fellows, the ten-person staff of the organization includes at least six people who have worked in Republican or conservative politics. The thirteen-person board leans even further to the right, and it’s fi lled with Republican donors. CSI’s board chair, Earl Wright, who is the co-founder and chairman of the board for AMG National Trust Bank, has donated at least $135,000 to Republican candidates and campaigns since 2010, ac- cording to state campaign fi nance records. Chris Brown, CSI’s vice president of policy and research, insists that the organi- zation’s research approach does not come from a “political lens.” Still, he concedes, “We believe in the free enterprise system and, to the extent that we have a bias or preference around things, I think we come at things from prioritizing the free enterprise system, and that includes a strong public sector, without a doubt.” CSI had a busy 2021, funded by $1.46 million in revenue. A quarter of that money came from individual donations, and the rest from foundations, businesses, associa- tions and chambers. The organization used those funds to assess various ballot initia- tives, including ones related to housing and homelessness in Denver. “The board and the staff make decisions together about what issues to undertake. We take on the most pressing issues the state is facing,” says Cinamon Watson, director of public relations for CSI. The think tank also analyzed jobs and the labor force in Colorado. But one of its biggest projects was a study on crime, released in December 2021. The crime report was released under a pair of high-powered fellows. Mitch Morrissey, a Democrat, served as Denver district at- torney from 2005 to 2017. George Brauchler, a Republican, served as district attorney for the 18th Judicial District, which covers Douglas, Arapahoe and Elbert counties, for eight years, wrapping up his tenure in January 2021. When the report came out in December, Shaun Boyd of CBS4 published a story in which Brauchler referred to the crime wave that Colorado has been experiencing with the much more hyperbolic “crime tsunami.” The headline of that online piece was “‘Crime Tsunami’: New Study By Two For- mer District Attorneys Finds Colorado’s Crime Rate Worse Than Other States.” Although the “crime tsunami” descrip- tion came from Brauchler — not from the reporter — Hugh McKean, a Republican and Colorado House minority leader, subsequently published a piece in Colorado Politics that cited the CSI study, and added that “some news headlines have gone so far as to call this a ‘crime tsunami,’” giving the term legitimacy and legs. But some experts would like to cut this report off at the knees. “This report wouldn’t meet the research standards of a freshman term paper,” says Christie Donner, executive director of the Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coali- tion, who is often on the opposite side of Donner says she’d never heard of CSI before the crime report was released. According to Watson, the crime study followed the same format used by CSI for other reports. “The entire team comes to the table and evaluates data that exists, gaps in the research, potential solutions, economic modeling, etc.,” she says. “It is a collabora- tive, iterative process between fellows and the staff at all points.” Brown stands by the research in the study. “When we establish these fellowships and we have a topic and we go out and look for the right people that are interested, we don’t edit what people offer in terms of an informed opinion or their background, or based on their background or experience,” he explains. But that use of non-scientifi c researchers is exactly why others criticize it. “Obviously, conservatives want to run on crime as a political agenda and to blame Democrats for rising crime. The CSI report on crime is consistent with that political agenda,” notes Armstrong. “George Brauchler is a prominent Republican expected to run for statewide offi ce again. True, co-author Mitch Morrissey was a Democratic DA, but DAs of- ten throw in with ‘law and order’ Republicans when it comes to criminal justice. As for the report itself, I think it indicates some potential problems, but that it also focuses on problems plausibly caused by Democrats and ignores many other relevant issues.” While the crime study has been used by Republicans to point to problems with the Democratic control of the state, the CSI’s homelessness study grabbed signifi cant at- tention in metro Denver. The fi rst phase of the study suggested George Brauchler and Mitch Morrissey were CSI fellows. “Crime has undeniably and dramatically increased over the last decade in Colorado,” the report states. “The primary and con- sistent policy trend in Colorado has been to discourage the jailing of those arrested for committing crimes and to reduce the severity of punishment for those convicted. However well-intended, these recent poli- cies must be monitored to ensure the costs from the unintended — albeit predictable — consequences do not outweigh the an- ticipated benefi ts.” “It is simply undeniable that the legis- lature over the last decade or so has made it easier to decrease penalties for criminal conduct,” Brauchler says, citing the creation of a framework that allowed for the more frequent granting of personal recognizance bonds. And the uptick in crime “seems to be happening at the same time.” “Those are things that I believe are having an impact in the increase in both property crimes and violent crimes,” Morrissey adds. The study generated a signifi cant amount of buzz, and although Brauchler and Mor- rissey both note that the report wasn’t de- signed to be partisan in nature, it’s also given Republicans some major talking points for this election year. Here’s how it worked in one case: that governmental, quasi-governmental and nonprofi t entities spend an estimated $434.6 million annually on homelessness in the City of Denver — a number highlighted in many headlines. “We were really proud. We actually took prosecutors like Brauchler and Morrissey when testifying at the Colorado Capitol. “I was actually pretty surprised at how shoddy this was.” “That’s not to say I disagree with every- thing that is in the report,” she adds. “My take on it is that it is sort of a conclusion in search of data to support, which is sort of a no-no in research reports. And even in say- ing that, there’s faulty assumptions, there’s dubious data sources, a lot of stats aren’t cited to a source at all, and there’s confl ict with known data sources. It’s weird, because you read the report and it’s like hair on fi re, hair on fi re, and buried deep in the report is an acknowledgment that the declining prison population doesn’t give evidence of a connection to an increase in crime.” “A correlation is not causation” is a “ri- diculous statement,” Brauchler responds. Brauchler’s view of that research axiom is exactly “why he shouldn’t be writing re- search reports,” Donner suggests. “It means whoever said that statement doesn’t un- derstand research and shouldn’t be writing a report. It’s an aggrandized op-ed. For people who are actually serious about this, we really do know the difference between what’s coincidence, what’s correlative and what’s causal.” an even more conservative approach in the numbers than I think a lot of other groups would have,” Strohm says. “In the 990 in- formation we pulled, we didn’t include any overhead expenditures, we didn’t include any fundraiser expenditures. I think at the end of the day, when people see that, they’ll realize that it’s a pretty conservative number.” However, some of the key service provid- ers and governmental entities highlighted in the report are not only critical of the research, but downright skeptical. “I thought there was a really good op- portunity to be illuminating, and they in- stead had questionable, if not fl at-out wrong, methodology, and likely made it more misin- formed than illuminating,” says Britta Fisher, chief housing offi cer for the City of Denver. While Strohm suggests that the study used conservative estimates, Fisher con- tends that there was “double counting” of funds and that researchers “just infl ated the numbers in a way that doesn’t make sense.” “It’s been in opinion pieces and some of the writing that different organizations put out. They cite that study, which I think is inaccurate,” Fisher says. “I think that un- derstanding the economics of our systems is helpful as we think about our approach for addressing homelessness in our community, in our city, our state, our country. But when FEBRUARY 10-16, 2022 WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | westword.com CSI