6 FEBRUARY 1-7, 2024 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | proposing that a ban be attached to the Na- tional Defense Authorization Act. The books on Boebert’s list were familiar subjects — and some were the same titles being challenged in other library districts and school boards not only in Colorado, but nationwide. Boebert’s attempt at censorship failed. During his time in Douglas County, LaRue estimates that he fi elded some 250 challenges to what the public library system offered: books, fi lms, magazines, music, even exhibits and speakers. And he’s currently in the midst of another controversy in Garfi eld County. According to the most recent data from the Library Research Service, challenges to materials and services in Colorado shot up 500 percent from 2021 to 2022, from 20 challenges (itself double the number in 2020) to 120. According to the American Library Association, there were 1,269 challenges re- ported nationally in 2022, giving Colorado the dubious distinction of being home to close to 10 percent of all library complaints that year. The ALA admits that these numbers are somewhat soft; reporting is voluntary, and historically some libraries have been either reticent or simply too busy to forward that information. In fact, the ALA estimates that up to 97 percent of challenges go unreported nationwide. About 83 percent of the challenges in this state were in some way related to LG- BTQIA+ issues, according to the LRS. The most commonly challenged book was the award-winning Gender Queer: A Memoir, by Maia Kobabe; the most frequently chal- lenged activities were assorted drag queen story hours around the state. While no data is yet available for 2023 (these reports are produced mid-year for the previous year), anecdotally the numbers look even higher than in 2022 — despite a success rate of only 1 in 100 for these challenges. Brooky Parks, librarian and mother of two, worked in the teen section of the Erie Community Library and, in December 2021, was fi red for her advocacy of LGBTQ+ and anti-racist programming. Her offense? Us- ing the term “woke” in a positive context. “We have board members that run a library based on their personal beliefs instead of what a library is supposed to be,” Parks told the Colorado Sun. She sued the district for wrongful termination and won her case in September 2023. In February 2022, the Gunnison County Library System received a complaint from a Crested Butte woman, one of the many state- and nationwide challenges to Kobabe’s Gender Queer. Her request to remove the book was denied, but it led to an even bigger issue about “patron confi dentiality” when the library identified the complainant to the media. While the woman had already outed herself in public meetings, the library changed its policy and now redacts personal information when sharing any “request for reconsideration” forms deemed newsworthy. That September, the public library system in Wellington was hit with a laundry list of books that one local woman considered “por- nographic,” including such award winners as Stephen Chbosky’s The Perks of Being a Wallfl ower and Toni Morrison’s acclaimed The Bluest Eye. The Coloradoan quoted a response from young resident Sienna Zadina: “Not to be rude, but you can’t tell me what I can and can’t read.” This not only turned out to be the overall community’s opinion, but it inspired an interesting solution from the town’s governing board. (Spoiler alert: See below.) In 2023, Academy School District 20 in Colorado Springs removed three books from its libraries following a letter of complaint from a conservative activist group. The Free- dom From Religion Foundation successfully fought the accusation of “inappropriate sexual and violent content,” War of the Words continued from page 5 continued on page 8 Banned on the Run What books have been challenged in this state? Here are fi fteen titles that star in recent Colorado cases, listed al- phabetically by the surname of their authors. All too often, these authors have dared to be inclusive about both race and LGBTQ+ issues. Clutch your pearls! The Perks of Being a Wallfl ower, Steven Chbosky The acclaimed Young Adult (YA) novel from 1999 (made into a hit fi lm in 2012) follows a young man through the perils of adolescence. Reasons for challenge: LGBTQ+ issues and sexual content. This Book Is Gay, Juno Dawson A frank and entertaining “instruction manual” on understanding gender and sexual identity. Reason for challenge: because it’s a frank and enter- taining “instruction manual” on understanding gender and sexual identity. Prison School, Akira Hiramoto One of the manga being attacked in Garfi eld County libraries, Hiramoto’s graphic novel is defi nitely meant for adults in terms of both its comedy and sexual con- tent, but it’s telling that one of the specifi c complaints was “It appears that a lot of people are pushing gay pride on children.” Reason for challenge: ostensibly for adult content, but clearly LGBTQ+ issues as well. Identical, Ellen Hopkins A New York Times best-selling novel about disturbing and dark family secrets. Reason for challenge: sexual content. Middle School’s a Drag, You Better Werk!, Greg Howard A comic YA novel about an enterprising boy who starts his own junior talent agency and signs a thirteen-year-old aspiring drag queen as his fi rst client. Reason for challenge: LGBTQ+ content. Some Girls Bind, Rory James A novel-in-verse about a young girl confronting her own ten- dency to bind and wondering if that means she’s “genderqueer.” Reason for challenge: LGBTQ+ issues. All Boys Aren’t Blue, George M. Johnson A series of essays that make up the memoir of journalist and activist George M. Johnson. Reason for challenge: Johnson’s activism was in support of the LGBTQIA+ community. Gender Queer, Maia Kobabe Maia Kobabe, who uses e/em/eir pronouns, presents an intense, honest and cathartic autobiography in graphic novel form. Reason for challenge: LGBTQ+ issues. The Hips on the Drag Queen Go Swish Swish Swish, Lil Miss Hot Mess A take-off on “The Wheels on the Bus” in which a drag queen does her routine in front of an appreciative audience. Reason for challenge: LGBTQ+ issues. Julián Is a Mermaid, Jessica Love Julián is a kid who likes to dress like a mermaid and run around in his underpants. Reason for challenge: As Lauren Boebert sneered, “He can freely express himself.” Let’s Talk About It: The Teen’s Guide to Sex, Relationships, and Being a Human, Erika Moen and Matthew Nolan This inclusive and accessible graphic novel offers a friendly guide to growing up, from gender and sexuality to consent and safe sex. Perfect for any teen starting to ask: Is what I’m feeling normal? Reason for challenge: sex, and an apparent need on the part of some parents to defi ne what “normal” is for everyone else. The Bluest Eye, Toni Morrison Morrison’s classic fi rst novel about race and identity focuses on a 1941 African-American family in Ohio, and is one of the true classics of twentieth-century literature. Reason for challenge: the attempted whitewashing of America. Jack of Hearts (and Other Parts), Lev A.C. Rosen Another YA novel having to do with young love and sexual identity, told in an unapologetic manner. Reason for challenge: LGBTQ+ issues, and probably that unapologetic part, too. Push, Sapphire The award-winning novel that was developed into the 2009 Oscar-winning fi lm Precious. Reason for challenge: supposedly sexual details, but race plays a far larger role in the book. Lucky, Alice Sebold The author of The Lovely Bones writes about her own harrow- ing experience suffering a brutal rape as a freshman in college. Reason for challenge: details of sexual assault and its aftermath. — BOHLEN James LaRue is a veteran public librarian whose latest book addresses censorship. JAMES L ARUE