10 JANUARY 12-18, 2023 westword.com WESTWORD | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | that the foundation’s attempts to introduce innovations had been stymied. “A player will make a recommendation on the game and we’ll be all excited about it,” Julie says. “Then I’ll call the Secretary of State and they go, ‘Oh, that’s not allowed in Colorado.’ And there’s no real reason why it’s not. … There’s no reason other than it’s not in our rules, but changing the rules is an act of God, practically.” God apparently wasn’t available in Novem- ber, when the Colorado ballot included Amendment F, a provision that would have changed some of the rules in the state consti- tution governing bingo, among them lifting the prohibition against paying those who run the games. Skilled workers create more lucrative games, according to the Colorado Charitable Bingo Association. Richard Lemon is a vice president of the CCBA; he’s also general manager of Rocky Mountain Bingo Supply, which sells bingo supplies across the Rocky Mountain region, including in New Mexico and Wyoming, where rules aren’t as restric- tive as they are in Colorado. “There’s a lot less rules and regulations,” Lemon says. “They seem to be able to make more money on an annual basis than we do. They are able to pay workers. Nonprofi ts are able to run bingo more like a business.” In Colorado, the only entities eligible for charitable gaming licenses for bingo are registered nonprofi ts that have existed for fi ve or more years. According to the Secretary of State’s Offi ce, 879 organizations are cur- rently licensed to run games. But under the law, the people running those games can’t be paid or even reimbursed for travel time. “No commission, salary, compensation, reward, or recompense can be paid to any person for holding, operating, or conducting bingo games,” reads the Secretary of State’s Bingo FAQ page. “This includes items like free sodas or snacks, tips, or anything of value given to a worker in exchange for working a bingo occasion. The proceeds must always be used for the group’s charitable purpose as stated in their articles, charter or by-laws.” The only allowable form of compensa- tion? One meal worth under $10 per shift. While the Chelsea Hutchison Foundation doesn’t have trouble fi nding good volunteers, Julie says she knows of other nonprofi ts that have problems fi nding people to work games. She’d also like to be able to pay some of the young adults who help out her foundation’s games and can’t hold a paying job because their epilepsy requires that they stay close to caregivers. “It would be life-changing for them to be able to be compensated in some manner, to give them the purpose of a job and restore that responsibility in a really, really safe en- vironment for them,” she says, noting that there’s always someone who knows how to respond to a seizure at foundation events. Since games of chance were enshrined in the Colorado Constitution, other forms of gambling have been approved in the state, including the Colorado Lottery, casinos, off-track betting on horse races, and sports betting. Social gambling between friends with no profi t motive is also allowed. But the only signifi cant change to bingo games since 1958 has been the addition of electronic cards to improve accessibility. The CCBA would like to see the rules governing bingo moved from the Colorado Constitution to state statute, which governs all of the other gambling options. “Colorado is very receptive to gambling,” says Corky Kyle, a lobbyist for the CCBA who also serves as its vice president. “All of those other venues have the ability to make changes more quickly without having to change the constitution. They do it through the regulatory boards that have oversight of them. … Unfor- tunately, bingo is the one that’s been left out.” The Colorado Lottery was created in 1983, after the Colorado Legislature put a proposal to allow it on the statewide ballot. Gambling proponents landed the Colorado Limited Gaming Initiative on the 1990 ballot; it called for an amendment to the state constitution that would allow casinos to open in Black Hawk, Central City and Cripple Creek and make oversight of those casinos a statutory issue. Voters approved the measure and have okayed updates to it since, expanding hours and the size of bets, among other things. In 2019, the legislature put Proposition DD on the ballot to legalize sports betting online and at casinos under the statutory and regulatory authority of the Colorado Divi- sion of Gaming. Voters approved that, too. “The other industries realize that they have to meet the needs of their players and, in order to meet the needs of the players, they’ve got to have fl exibility through the regulatory process and the legislative pro- cess,” Kyle says. Bingo doesn’t have that fl exibility. In- stead, it has the Colorado Bingo-Raffle Advisory Board, whose nine members are appointed by the president of the Colorado Senate and the Speaker of the House. Ac- cording to Kyle, the board isn’t particularly powerful, because it can only make recom- mendations, not decisions. The board can conduct market studies, though, which it last did in 2017. That bingo and raffl e study found that bingo isn’t doing well, with both revenues and profi t margins decreasing as the game has struggled to retain both consistent volunteers and play- ers. And it needs to reach a new audience in order to supplement the aging population that typically plays bingo, the study noted. “A lot of my closest friends, they still don’t know what I do,” says Lemon, who has been in the bingo industry for decades. “They haven’t been to bingo and probably never will. They still think it’s all down in the church basement. Every time we do something different, it does help. It does create profi tability.” Amendment F would have reduced the amount of time an organization has to be in existence as a registered nonprofi t before applying for a license from fi ve years to three. It also would have repealed the ban on paying managers and operators of charitable gam- ing activities. Under F, those workers could have been paid minimum wage until 2024, at which point the legislature could determine whether any changes needed to be made. Amendment F went down, tough, as did a similar proposal in 2020 that called for pay- ing workers but did not include a provision to move decision-making to the legislature. Both measures were referred to the ballot by the legislature with bipartisan support. Before pushing for the amendments, the CCBA had tried to negotiate with the Sec- retary of State’s Offi ce to allow paid callers for games, but was told the rule couldn’t be changed without a vote of the people since it is in the Colorado Constitution. That helped inspire the push for Amendment F. “In order to get any signifi cant change, you have to change the constitution,” Lemon says. “Right or wrong, a lot of people don’t like that. We’re kind of small potatoes. It’s nonprofi ts, so there’s not a whole lot of money to be made running election campaigns.” In fact, Lemon says, the CCBA’s budget for the Amendment F campaign was just $5,000. And the proposal faced strong op- position from the Veterans of Foreign Wars, which argued that the proposed changes would create the same kinds of problems the casino industry now faces; the VFW warned that out-of-state companies would profi t off Coloradans and take all the benefi ts for themselves while making it impossible for small and local players to stay in the game. The Colorado VFW rallied local posts to oppose Amendment F. According to Bruce Dolan, the state adju- tant and quartermaster for the VFW Depart- ment of Colorado, charitable gaming is the lifeblood for many VFW posts across the state, which use bingo and raffl es to fi nance their work, including providing grave and memo- rial services for veterans. “You get outside entities coming into the state, and they start having bigger and bigger prizes than any of the nonprofi ts could afford to match,” Dolan says. That’s simply not the case, responds the CCBA. “They’re very dedi- Numbers Game continued from page 9 continued on page 11 After Chelsea Hutchison (above, far right) died, her parents started a foundation partially funded by bingo games that attract regulars like the McDonalds. “We set out on a mission to raise awareness because we didn’t want any other families to be blindsided.” COURTESY OF THE HUTCHISON FAMILY CHELSEA HUTCHISON FOUNDATION