10 August 21-27, 2025 miaminewtimes.com | browardpalmbeach.com NEW TIMES | MUSIC | CAFE | CULTURE | NIGHT+DAY | NEWS | LETTERS | CONTENTS | which include guava, passion fruit, and roasted coconut. You can even customize your own key lime concoction with the baker (within reason). Not a fan of Florida’s official pie? Miss Debbie’s Sweet Delights also offers a “Love Cake,” which is made with vanilla and coconut and tastes like actual human af- fection. Order by phone (786-728-2666) or email ([email protected]); pies and cakes are available for delivery or pickup in Cutler Bay, but no walk-ins. Publix Supermarket Locations across Miami and Florida Hear us out. Publix’s original key lime pie is the tastiest store-bought key lime pie in Mi- ami — and it actually gives some restaurant- made ones a run for their money. For 24 years, Publix pies have brought home blue ribbons at the National Pie Championships, including in 2025 when its original key lime pie won in the “Best Mini Pie” category and in the “Large Pie” category. Plus, it’s so good, it even won New Times’ Best Key Lime Pie 2024. Made with authentic key limes, the filling is light yet lush with just the right amount of tartness. It’s also nestled in a crumbly, buttery graham cracker crust. Al- though it says it serves about eight or nine people, who are we kidding — dig in with a spoon all by yourself. Any pie is a single-serv- ing pie if you put your heart into it. Whisk Gourmet 7382 SW 56th Ave., South Miami 754-345-8821 whiskgourmet.com Featured on Food Network’s Diners, Drive- Ins & Dives with Guy Fieri, Whisk Gourmet in South Miami is a hidden gem where no visit is complete without their made-from- scratch key lime pie. Since opening in 2011, this tart, creamy, and perfectly balanced des- sert, made with a graham cracker crust that has just the right amount of crunch, has been a local favorite. It’s not fancy, it’s honestly not that pretty, and they place sliced strawber- ries on top of the whipped cream for garnish, but it’s so well done here that you’ll find yourself debating whether to order a second slice... (just do it). [email protected] Joe’s Stone Crab photo Joe’s Stone Crab makes some of the most mouthwatering key lime pie in Miami Pie Detector from p9
